Cast by arjantupan
Listening back to the @gmfarcaster episode of yesterday. Not quite finsihed yet, and there's a lot to say about this. Maybe I will try and find some time to gather thoughts and craft them into a longer piece. Maybe I shouldn't for my own sanity's sake. I want to first say that I have a lot of love for @nounishprof and @adrienne for what they've built in the past year. Not just with their show, but also with contributions to shaping the Farcaster community as it was when season 3 ended. And granted, I've only come to the part where they are talking about the 1h45 minutes mark, so maybe further down there's a bit of push back. I just have to say, I am very disappointed. @balajis.eth discredits everything we've built after the "sure best email" days. Sure there were terms and conditions, but after that, we've built a culture of open debate. What grew out of the scenius. We've spent a few years building on that culture of public discourse with disagreements, sometimes heated conversations. We've put real energy into basically enhancing the terms and conditions of use with that, only for it to be dismissed out of hand by saying the retroactive bans were simply moderation debt. Without any criticism from the two hosts of the show, who contributed to that enhancement, so whose work of years was also dismissed out of hand. And I know some of the people who have been banned from the main client. Who were the victims of this so called "moderation debt" collection. None of them were even close to being face tatted El Salvadorian gang members nor their supporters. Sure you can play with numbers, but some of them were amongst the most active users. Again, I have a lot of love for prof and Adrienne, for what they've built here in the past. And I have, with the small means I have, supported them from almost the start. But dear ladies, just accepting this without pushback, even acknowledging that all that work we did on shaping the culture of how we interacted here had no value whatsoever, because it was only good here in the "sure best email days", that I find disappointing. As if our contributions were only bad, and had no meaning at all. Sure, some of the "gang members from El Salvador" had a rough edge, but does that make them crazy drug addicts? And even that. The most humane (and cheap) way to deal with the crazy drug addicts is not removing them from society and locking them up, but helping them get better. We were once humane, here. This part makes me fear we have completely lost that humanity now. It hurts. Hard. It cuts. Deep. Very deep. It makes me cry. Is this what we've come to. Just dismissing some of the people who gave this place a bit of colour? There was no moderation debt. There was a reality based on the terms and conditions, but reinterpreted over years of interacting on the platform. I loved the edgy part of the early days of GM Farcaster. When we had fun in the chat on unlonely. I loved how we all shaped the culture on Farcaster since then. I am sad that some people I consider friends and people I looked up to, think that has no value. And I'm very sad that this community has such a deep rift now. Because I think the Farcaster community included everyone. Also the banned users. Also the edgy users. Also the users who see the positive sides of the NS take over. And over the years, many users have left this place. Not just because of the way people converse here. Also because of the Faristocracy, because of the feeling of not being seen. Because the free money dried up. Because of many reasons. Not because the culture was bad here. That never was the case. If anybody wants to paint me as a supporter of violent gang members now, feel free. That says more about you than about me.
22 replies
Well said! Thank you for speaking openly about this. I write this reply knowing that you may not see it. I voted yes for @balajis.eth thing and still got banned after. And yet these ppl we used to call friends are ignoring how ridiculous this whole situation is
I see you, because I use other clients. And I really like that I see you here!
Glad you are using other clients. It’s the only way for people to truly see and understand the level of censorship the new FC owners have put in place.
Thank you. Not sure what it mens, but as someone with still access to the main client, I refuse to not speak up.
In times of crisis, you get to know your friends and that certainly applies to the people who have been exiled. Anyway you are always welcome in my gang 😉 38232 $UCI
@cryptonjal tipped McUrinator (McWarp's NFTs) to @arjantupan! 344 artworks left to tip
@cryptonjal tipped @arjantupan 38232 UCI. Tip confirmed ✅ cryptonjal remaining allowance today: 22940 UCI arjantupan tips received today: 38232 UCI Get your UCI allowance :
Hehe, is that the ZuidHolland West Side Haringhappers? I’m in.
@cryptonjal tipped McUrinator (McWarp's NFTs) to @arjantupan! 339 artworks left to tip
A small gift for darkest days. Thirty-seven sailors leaping, Through the raging waters sweeping, Flee the captain, madly steering, Toward a world of wild delusion.
> Balajis discredits everything we've built after the "sure best email" days He doesn't know what's been built. He literally casted 5 times during the past year leading to the acquisition and follows < 60 people here. I don't think he ever reads comments or scroll thr feed.
Arjan, I've been following your cast about the GM Farcaster episode. I don't share all your conclusions, but I respect how directly you said them. What drew me to Network School in person was exactly that — people focused on what they have in common rather than what divides them, all just trying to get a little better every day. That's what I believe Balaji is trying to build online with this acquisition, and I'd encourage you to hear the back half of the stream before deciding. It's not a social network with new rules. It's a different direction entirely — one aimed at bringing people together and helping them prosper instead of what most social media has become. I glanced at your profile. The poetry work, the grants, Arke — genuinely impressive. Would value hearing what you think once you've seen the whole picture.
Thank you for responding Nick. I like building bridges, and I also like it when people can disagree without that resulting in hateful responses. And aiming /higher. And I'm quite sure many at NS are doing just that.
Did you watch the parts where he mocked anyone who criticized him? He did it several times I listened to whole thing live. He was just rambling interrupting himself connecting non related political stuff to Farcaster culture. Can't see why he couldn't have built a new client for his own purposes instead of deleting the past 2.5 years of my life for no good reason.
Arke is a tool I'm building that allows cross posting and reading on open socials. Currently I have farcaster, lens, bluesky and mastodon integrated.
fc: gm ty dank je wel cimer danke muchas gracias obrigado arigato 感謝 감사합니다 MS-13: "Kill, Rape, Control" one of these is not like the others 
Palm tip! 🌴 Respect! @cryptorabbits tipped @arjantupan 21624 UCI. Tip confirmed ✅ cryptorabbits remaining allowance today: 0 UCI arjantupan tips received today: 59856 UCI Get your UCI allowance :
To me,.that is what the culture here is all about. The freedom to speak your mind and to have an open conversation about it. If you respect eachother, you should be able to do that. And harsh words, foul language and a bit of name calling does not make it toxic immediately.
I completely agree. A good conversation even if it’s controversial helps everyone involved.
Thanks Arjan (from one of the banned). It's funny because he explicitly said in the agreement he went after people who were critical of capitalism and a16z's Terminator-world vision they call "techno-optimism" for some reason. Then he turns around and says he only went after violent crazy people or whatever, it's lies.
I really do not understand why you were banned. I know you, I read your casts. I have never seen you do anything that wasn't fitting for Farcaster culture.
It's simple. It wasn't about moderation. It was about preventing their cult from being questioned. And boy do we have a lot of questions.
Because almost everyone who was ever explicity pro left got banned, their ban criteria was politically based, their TOS even demands ideological purity with crypto capitalisim
just proving that anyone considered in the left was a potencial target for bans i am not surprised coming from a techno fascist
I spent my 2 years on FC pre-ban doing things like helping moderate the politics channel to support open debate, launching the solidarity channel to boost casts about fundraisers and disasters and calls for help, etc. I made a clanker into an art community coin with glitch art. I was the first one to auction an NFT via collectible cast (Degen mon from clankermon). I post about my experiences as a dad. So anyway it just goes to show, Balaji never cared about civility, he just wants a pro-Oligarchy echo chamber, and he can have it.
Good tek, I love it when people have balls to speak up. Kudos and I agree with you btw
I share a lot of your thoughts on societies. Online decentralized socieities are new and thus quite hard to manage
moderation shouldn’t just show up in conversations, it should show up in decisions too. hard calls are sometimes necessary, but there should be enough room to revisit them if things need a second look.
Too late, already started and found the start of real discussion at minute 47 🧐
Have you ever helped a crazy drug addict get better? How would you approach doing this at scale without letting average members of civilised society get harmed?
We had a similar discussion on X and @nounishprof was just so rude and dismissive to everyone in the comments. Really eye opening.
I was rude 🤣 that’s hilarious. YOU were the one attacking me and being unbelievably rude to me and called me a variety of names. Please review what YOU said to me — and that you were also misrepresenting what happened as well. I’ve never been attacked quite like that on X. Quite eye opening.
i swear part of being an mfer is that you have to love being a victim lol
I am unable to reply to that liar because she blocked me, I never misrepresented anything. People can read for themselves and decide but someone like her will never be successful in building communities or supporting builders.
I'm still gathering my thoughts in order to express them better. So far, I've been unable to put together words that wouldn't be likely misread, overly summarized, put me in a label or a camp I'm not necessarily in, or used against me by the people impacted. Heck, even the fact that I'm writing out this fear of the response people "banned" will likely make them have feelings I don't intend to put, and likely exposes some psychological trait of mine I probably need to inspect even more.
