Cast by darrylyeo
Show the cast this replies toOn @balajis.eth. He likes analogies. A lot. If you’re still here, you’re gonna have to get used to it. Best advice if you aren’t familiar with his content (or only have secondhand impressions): read the *stated definition* of the network state from his book, watch at least one of his long-form podcasts or conference talks on YouTube all the way through, do your own research on the cited history, and take the best-faith interpretation of the adjectives and proper nouns he chooses to invoke. You’re not immediately going to agree with everything he does and says, or how he says it, or even the circle of elites he associates with – and that’s okay. But you *can* count on him to be awfully clear and consistent about the observations he does make, grounded in a breadth of technical and historical context you wouldn’t otherwise hear about, and as a result very often directionally correct in the long term.
2 replies
Two things worth calling out (because I already see friends eager to misrepresent things): One – the ability to opt-in, fork or exit at any time is *literally the entire premise* of the Network State movement. You join any place or ecosystem because you like a curated set of values, rules and incentives. If it turns out you don’t love @ns’s, that’s okay. You’re actively encouraged to fork off and start a competing vision. No one will force you to continue spending time on the flagship @farcaster client or at @ns’s campus if you don’t want to. Two – @balajis.eth is not seeking to be a tyrant or a dictator. Ask him during @ns Lunch-and-Learn what his personal ambitions are within the Network State project, and he will consistently respond “Minimum-Viable Balaji”. He may also liken himself to a “reluctant” Lee Kuan Yew who peacefully sets a system in motion before passing the torch. Yes, the Singapore analogy is contradictory in isolation. The onus is on you to hear the full context.
On the premise of the @ns × @farcaster merger. As I’ve posted about in the /network-states channel, I’ve been to both Forest City and Kazakhstan, and I’ve seen the Network School core team in action. They’re some of the smartest and hardest working “government employees” I know. Operationally, they’re just like any other tech startup, iterating on a minimum viable product to validate or invalidate a number of unproven theses. It doesn’t surprise me at all that @balajis.eth ended up being the fabled “third bidder” to take over from @neynar, because one of his long-running theses is “technodemocracy”. Turns out, Balaji has been consistently touting the idea of Farcaster as a crypto-enabled *governance platform* for years, both internally to his audience at @ns and at conferences like Token2049. If you want the full context on what’s happening, you’re gonna want to watch this talk all the way through 👇
Knowing all this – it saddens me to see that the technodemocracy experiment imposed on Farcaster's flagship user base on day one *preemptively barred people from participating* in the vote over weird / stupid things they said years ago. They had no choice but to exit their keys, scramble to boot up another client, and work around new API restrictions just to get their normal experience back. Honestly, not cool. Brutal first impression for an incoming steward of an aspiring credibly neutral protocol. "Step one" seriously undermined the premise of "Step two" and erased a lot of emergent culture and community goodwill. What's most jarring is that I think many people who were left out are quite conscious about CROPS values and would otherwise be quite aligned with Network State ideas, but they are needlessly fearful and resentful now. To my Farcaster friends who were abruptly forced to leave, or are totally put off by this transition and/or its premise – I understand completely, and I'll miss you here. 💔
"You're actively encouraged to Fork Off" I see what you did there
Tee-hee. I’d have said “fork the entire stack” but I ran out of characters 🪗