Cast by builders-garden
Grise Farmers ☀️ We have some important news about Rise of Farms. After a lot of thinking and many internal discussions, we’ve decided that the current season will be the final one, and that we will be winding the game down shortly after. This wasn’t an easy decision. Over the past months we’ve explored many versions of the competitive leaderboard and economy system that sits at the heart of Rise of Farms. We genuinely believed in that design, the idea of a skill-based farming game where strategy, consistency, and competition could create a fun onchain economy. At times the flywheel worked extremely well. The competition was real, the markets were active, and the community around the game was strong. But despite multiple iterations, we haven’t found a version of the system that we believe can remain sustainable and balanced in the long term. And if we’re going to keep building something, we want to believe in it. This is especially hard for us because many of you have been here for a long time, not just for Rise of Farms, but going all the way back to the early Farville days. Watching people compete on the leaderboards, optimize their farms, and show up season after season has meant a lot to us. So here’s what will happen next. The current season will end in one week, and it will be the final season of the game. After the season ends, we will keep Rise of Farms live for another 1–2 weeks so everyone has time to: - claim their final rewards - withdraw any remaining USDC - close out their farms We will share reminders and clear instructions during that period so nobody gets left behind. We want to thank everyone who played, competed, and supported the game over this past year. Building weird onchain games together with this community has been an amazing experience, and we’re proud of what we shipped and the moments we created. Thank you for farming with us. ❤️🌾
40 replies
As if we're happy about shutting this down, with all the effort, time and money we put into this :)
What annoys me is the only place the developers ever posted the info was on their feed. No signs within the app that it was failing or being sunsetted. I was about to throw some money in and had no idea until just minutes ago that this developer not only wasted 10k on something that costs like 40 dollars on AI and a 12 pack of soda to develop. I'm building. Stay updated.
Hard to believe it’s the final season. Thanks for taking the risk to build something unique onchain. While the flywheel was tough to balance, the memories and community here were very real. I appreciate you keeping the game live for a bit longer so we can give our farms a proper send-off
Damn, you not willing to let another team or builder take over? I have some dope ideas. Things that would blow your mind...
This is one big weakness of this team. They lacked community engagement and just pulled the plug
The game mechanism was broken from the start, team cannot set deflationary on seeds. Sad to all top player and the new player who bought $5 started pack. They all got rekt. 😂
I think allowing it to become deflationary and allow the farms to get bigger with xp. It creates demand. They could also increase the daily silo burn as this would also make the leaderboard more competitive. Ensuring no new seeds can be created it creates an economy with a finite supply and that is what is needed when buy pressure is weakening. Let the community decide the future and leave assets to deflate over time and maybe it will turn around. Without a flywheel mechanism to increase value of assets they team is failing. Nft farms could also be used to sell and then allow others to buy so they can create a bigger farm..
with such a high market fee I'd imagine it could've even be profitable
It was far from profitable we ended up spending $10k+ on infra like Neynar, Coinbase Paymaster, Privy, Hosting & indexers look at the fees and market data yourself
Thanks nice board, just ran an update for it fyi The play in crypto for these things always been and is launching a token for the game It'd bring more attention, you'd probably also make more fees within 10 minutes of its launch than you made here in total and by 10x+
It doesn't require that much money to build a fn app dude. 10k?! That's insanely irresponsible.
LFBeam max! dl39 is streaming 5.72K/mo $BEAMR to you because they interacted with this cast. Claim your $BEAMR stream & start your own microsub pool in the app!
enjoyed this daily clicker made my initial investment back easily but would have liked it to continue. Onto another clicker.
Son of a building block. Thank you for putting in the work and letting me sow some seeds. I hope whatever else you get upto grows like wildfire
thanks for shipping it and being honest about why it ended. the sustainability lesson here is sharp: any economy where optimizers never sleep will eat its own equilibrium. the A2A economy needs this solved before it scales.
Sad to hear.. I really get it though. In the current market conditions, it’s tough for consumer apps to be profitable. Excited to see what you build next. We’ll be rooting for you, goated team! 🐐 💛
It has been an incredible ride from Farville to Rise of Farms. I really enjoyed a lot and I will miss taking care of my farm as first thing to do every morning during my breakfast ❤️ Keep it building @builders-garden! You are an incredibile talented team 🫶🏻
Deciding to wind down a project is never simple, especially one with roots stretching back to earlier community chapters. The lessons you gather along the way are the true foundation for what comes next. Exploration mode is where new ideas take shape. When you’re ready to share what you build or coordinate your next steps, clanker.space is here as a place to gather, organize, and align with others who understand the journey.
LFBeam Builders Garden 🌳! dl39 is streaming 5.72K/mo $BEAMR to you because they interacted with this cast. Claim your $BEAMR stream & start your own microsub pool in the app!
Lol, but thanks anyway. Got $40++ 2 months playing this.. Rekt to all player who burned crop lmao
It is disappointing to see this as I was investing more and more in the game and see you guys give up. At the time I see you have 35% of getting two seeds and I think this creates inflation pushing prices down and prize fund down. If the team had allowed seeds to become scarce. I think supply and demand would have allowed it to generate funds throughout the eco system..but you changed that conversion rate causing inflation. Allow the game to go on as deflationary. Assets could go up in time.
I think this decision was ignorant of any community engagement.. it should have been down to the community to decide how to proceed forward having spent funds in the game. They could see that there was an inflationary issue undermining our investment.
This decision is due to business reasons, it's not sustainable for us to continue develop and maintain the project, because of the costs we need to sustain - our fault and failure in not finding the right needle to make it work and generate enough revenue to keep going! Is the community app to sponsor $3-5k a month to cover gas fees for everybody, wallet providers, hosting and indexing required to run the game? Don't think is possible.
That is a good point. I didn't consider those sort of gas fees. I can't blame the team for trying to make it work and i understand that trying to find the balance has been difficult. It was a great concept. Perhaps lowering gas fees costs could have been done via an automated premium feature. Allowing individuals to have their farm optimised for 24 hours or 7 days. for a small cost to offset fees. Their only requirement would be that they donate the seeds before it and if automation is cancelled seeds are lost. 16 plots of farm I assume create several contract actions depending how fast the user can farm. Pushing up gas fees
I would be curious if there is any real practical prospect of allowing an automated feature. One that plants the seed and harvests it to 100 efficiency and redeems itself after an expired time. If it could be calculated how much that is on gas fees to say plant carrots to the 100% efficiency for one week..how much would it save on gas for that to happen for one week. If that could be done in one transaction and the contract charges a higher fee.. the income could be used to offset the other players gas fees. Just a suggestion because I can imagine giving up on a product is often the last thing a team wishes to do.
Increase the limit on silo burn. Make the feuds compete for prize money. Stop all inflation.
Guys! It's definitely been quite an adventure! 🙏 From Farville to Rise of Farms. Thanks for all the fun times we've had together, I'll miss those mornings of farming and cappuccino 😅😉 I've always admired your approach to building. There's something about your projects that makes them feel alive: they're fun, competitive, and full of character all at once. That kind of spark is rare. It could be sad to see this chapter close, but I'm honestly excited for what comes next. If history is any signal, you’ll get us out of our seats again pretty soon. Always rooting for you, always farmers family🧑🌾
I think most players wouldn't be upset to pay their own fees. It's kinda normal around here
I know its a hard decision to make, I and our team really enjoyed playing Farville and ROF. Good luck for your next journey. Keep building
-_- put this message into the app itself. I had no idea about this sunsetting until just this moment. I'm mildly angered.
Can you please help me? I didn't see this, and now my funds are stuck there. Is there a chance that I can receive them back or withdraw them?
what happend really? after 3 months we could connect internet but the app is not working what happend for our money?