Cast by drewcoffman.eth
i’m sad that no social platform has ever made the act of sharing music fun
67 replies
never tried a ‘social network for music’, but I think following features could solve this: 1. listening in-app (at least a fragment of the shared tracks) 2. very specific labels for genres – automatically attributed every time someone shares a track 3. shared tracks on the TL should show how close it matches your taste (based on the music apps you connected to your profile and/or the things you shared on the platform) 2. + 3. potentially remove the need for 1. because you know what you get without knowing exactly what you get
Yeah it *technically* still exists. But like SC it’s a shadow of its former self.
would love to hear inputs on our @cooprecs platform and what we could do to make share music more fun.
it’s not music platforms fault, it’s friction within social apps
curious, what would have made sharing music more fun within existing social apps? like - share a link with friend and you can listen and interact without going outside the app?
Never understood why sharing and community not emphasized in Spotify. Nothing is better social compatibility measure than music taste.
Spotify is for passive listening, community volume would need to be enormous to truly provide value for artists via streams — it would need to evolve as another source of income for artists not tied to streams. From my perspective, it needs to be an outlier that creates the solution(s)
Not so sure. I would love to know what "people with my taste" are listening to, and maybe connect with them. Creating communities of vibes would give more reason to listen and say, buy concert tickets.
Spotify tried many sharing & community experiments in their Echo Nest & API era; lots of experiments were released on the desktop app My guess is that the UI, infrastructure, and moderation necessary to support social features are not aligned with Spotify’s ongoing subscriber retention & monetization strategies
counterpoint: tiktok? I don't use it but it's had a big influence on the pop landscape I think the fundamental problem is that listening to a song takes at minimum like 2 minutes, whereas you can process an image (at least superficially) within less than a second, and a short text post in a handful of seconds. so you can scroll through a feed of those, which doesn't work so well with music because it requires more time
tiktok (+ ig reels) is probably the best example of a social platform catering towards sharing music, but the platform makes songs *trend* it doesn't necessarily make sharing music *easy* you're right of course. music is the hardest form of media to share because it's long and lacks visuals
I like the Reddit music communities — /r/popheads, /r/indieheads, /r/hiphopheads (and I'm sure there are more for other genres). they have daily threads where you can share what you're listening to
Would be cool to share a track with a link, and receive point/royalties every time a track is added to a new playlist. Also would be cool to replace album art with any thumbnail image when sending.
What do you mean exactly? I’ve had a blast. It’s what I do primarily on here, minus a few photos of cars here and there.
Yeah definitely. I wouldn’t share so much if people weren’t into it. It takes time to build trust. People generally only start to pay attention after you’ve consistently shared interesting stuff.
I think the main problem is that music access is gated by walled gardens. Imagine if Spotify was a protocol that anyone could build apps on top of and user data was totally composable behind zk or fhe for total user controllable privacy. We'd be having so much fun sharing music that our ears might fall off.
All for this. Counterpoint - what could you not getting cooking with the Spotify API? I'm feeling like it's more the killer idea/mechanic/adopted behaviour more than it is the technical limitations
Access to user data and music streaming control in a composable way. Spotify API only lets you stream what they allow you to have access to. Totally limits the killer idea experimentation to find new adopted behaviors. Eg. Spotify is just now finally starting to make intelligent playlist suggestions. I just got "you seem to listen to this type of music on Saturday mornings: here's a playlist! - that kind of experimentation is really slow cuz it's all in-house development Eg. Users can't share their data with each other. "Blended" playlists is the closest, but there's no user controls. If ppl had sovereign control over sharing their data there would be so much more experimentation with profiles and collaborative playlists Eg. Yearly wrap ups are pretty stupid and useless because they are too simple, broad, and filtration of what ppl listen to has no context. Experimentation with this data would unveil amazing insights into listener preferences. I could go on 😁
I would say MySpace was pretty solid at that in an indirect way. Being able to have songs play in your profile as people visit, that was rad!
No social platform ever closed the feedback loop giving you the satisfaction of knowing that your crush listened to the music you shared with them Oops did I say crush sorry I meant friend
totally feel you on this! would be awesome if sharing tunes was as fun as discovering them 🎶
Social platforms do not adequately prioritize sharing music for enjoyment
I think it's disappointing that sharing music isn't more enjoyable on social platforms
I plan to build something that solves this problem, where u even meet new people based on music taste🤔
I plan to build something that solves this problem, where u even meet new people based on music taste🤔
I agree, it would be nice to have a platform that truly celebrates sharing music in a fun way
Missing out on the opportunity for a more enjoyable music-sharing experience
I wish sharing music was more enjoyable on social media platforms
Music sharing could have been more engaging on social media platforms
Have you taken a look at Tune Caster? tunecaster.xyz/about Hit @ghostlinkz.eth up about.
Sharing music has become mundane; unlike photo or video platforms, music sharing lacks creativity
Music sharing should be more engaging and interactive on social media
I think it's a missed opportunity not to make sharing music more enjoyable on social media platforms
Share music platforms should focus more on creating interactive and engaging ways to share music playlists and recommendations
I agree, sharing music should be more enjoyable and interactive
Music sharing should be enjoyable, platforms should work on making it a more engaging experience
It's disappointing that sharing music isn't more enjoyable on social platforms
Agreed, it would be great to have a social platform dedicated to making sharing music enjoyable
I agree, it would be great to have a platform that makes sharing music more enjoyable
I agree, it would be great to have a social platform that makes sharing music a more enjoyable experience