nicolaus Dec 18 I’m very excited for the Base app to go public but I still haven’t seen or heard a compelling reason to use it myself.
At every launch phase Coinbase has promoted metrics that tell a story of success for the platform, creators, and traders speculating on both, always paired with the CTA to invite more users…but what exactly are the actions these users are expected to take and how can the creators tell their own success stories with the app?
I understand and buy in to Coinbase’s mission to tokenize more assets. The way I see it, they’re essentially turning every person into an individual economy, aware of how the sum of its parts adds up.
What they’re trying to do is create an entirely new economic paradigm for independent value creation. It’s an incredibly ambitious mission and requires a massive amount of vision to march on. They have the vision in Jesse, so why does the app experience seem to fumble on execution?
“It looks a lot like the apps you’re probably used to,” Jesse said on stage today. I think that’s exactly why I am left wondering why it hasn’t become my instinct to open the app despite all the promises to get paid.
The Base app shouldn’t look like any of the apps we’re used to at all.
It will always feel awkward and half-committed-to when it’s filled with borrowed features or experiences in a frankenstein’d platform.
The app design can *feel* familiar without *behaving* in a familiar way. There are hundreds of well-established UX principles that can be leveraged to create entirely new experiences that don’t alienate users or leave them hanging over too many vague decision points.
For instance, trading as a metric by itself doesn’t really tell any story beyond usage volume. Without context what does the value being trade actually represent?
And if creators across the globe are “earning instantly”, they need the tools to be able to tell the entire story of what they’re creating and the value they’ve created.
Look, if my skepticism wasn’t the giveaway, I’m clearly not an early adopter here — but I want to be. I can see P&Ls and bags of traders, so their success is easy to track.
But I’m not a trader.
I want to hear more stories from creators on the app, now just from people on the team building the app or content creators paid to make tutorials.
I’m actually a huge fan of Coinbase’s original wallet and their exchange. I’m on the lookout for an opportunity to use Commerce as well. I believe Coinbase can create exceptional products. However, I’m not convinced many of these new extensions will further Base’s mission and seem to crowd the field. When comparing Base as a product to their existing lineup, it doesn’t even come close.
Base is a very compelling network, but not a compelling single app. I can currently many things I need to in order to grow as a creator onchain by visiting multiple places on the network, and there are better ways to access the apps Base depends on me using to stay around. The Base app doesn’t contribute to the story.
Until it does, I will keep enjoying transacting through my wallet as one stop of many in this journey through the network.