Cast by vgr
The fundamental idiocy of memecoins is the belief that trading useless information at warp speed somehow makes it useful. Like there’s some special relativity type law that increases the mass of objects as they approach the speed of light. A dumb joke is not worth a billion dollars simply because you traded a penny 100 billion times in an hour. Or because you took out a million dollar flash loan for 1 minute to participate in it. If you trade it fast enough at sufficient volume it doesn’t magically turn into Nvidia or Google stock. Buy the rumor/sell the news is at least a plausible strategy. Buy the rumor/sell the rumor with nothing ever rising to the level of news is noise. Trading sadly is about the rate at which actually materially new information enters a market and is priced in in some proportion to how it’s actually transforming the world. Not about how fast your clever machine can spin it around. And most information worth trading on is boring and banal, not culturally stimulating. If you want a vivid demonstration of this, go look at Vegas slot machines. The nickel and dime slots often have stimulating “narratives” based on latest licensed Hollywood movies etc. The more serious dollar slots have boring interfaces with less jazz. Nickel/dime/quarter slots are basically slow ways to lose money while being mildly “entertained” by hooks into cultural ephemera. Fast food kid meals with cheap toys. Table games like poker and blackjack and sports betting try to articulate real information markets (about player skills). Still not stuff I’d bet on but at least I can respect it. A sports bettor is at least doing meaningful hard thinking about real information about skilled people doing skilled things. For the same reason, I can respect prediction markets though I don’t play in that casino either. Bullshit “narratives” are a tell of low-stakes gambling dungeons. If you’re going to run a casino economy, at least run a good casino. All this applies to creator coins/writer coins too. I see no mechanisms that elevate those games above the memecoin game.
3 replies
very mid take disillusionment in crypto often stems from a fundamental error in timeline analysis. speculation funds infra. this is a historical fact: South Sea Bubble (Corporate Finance) British Railway Mania (Rail Transport) Roaring Twenties (Auto/Grid) Dot-com Bubble (Fiber/Internet)
This is bullshit and a false analogy. You’re conflating the Carlotta Perez installation/deployment cycle model of ~80y with tulip manias. This argument was somewhat true in 2017-20 but not since then. Infra development is a function of the value of eth itself, which primarily moves in response to the technical success of recent infra upgrades (internal signal from hard forks) and the value of competing crypto and trad assets. Memecoin economies may help test new infra on the margins but they do not fund it either directly or indirectly. They merely let bit players feel good for a while. I’d maybe buy that for stablecoins and restaking. Not for memecoins. Your argument is like saying casinos in mining towns helped build railroads. No. The prospect of mineral and farm economy wealth and infrastructure needs themselves (like atomic research and Hoover dam in Vegas) built railroads. Casinos in railroad towns like Vegas gave degens something to do around stuff being built by other forces. Effect not cause. Same applies to cable boom, shipping boom etc. Just because excess capacity was used by garbage doesn’t mean it was built for or by garbage.
the difference between speculation and prediction
oh man ignoring reality will not help ur pov bubbles have repeatedly expanded capital markets that later funded enduring infrastructure ur timeline is off
„disillusionment in crypto often stems from a fundamental error in timeline analysis“ is the funniest high brow insult you could have brought here 😂 come on disillusionment in crypto stemms 99.999999% of the time from the fact that we sold the people one thing („we‘re going to save the world“) and then switched to anther thing that provided way less meaning („actually it‘s just a casino“)
Couldn’t writers give writer coins value by making them necessary to access their content??