Cast by aviationdoctor.eth

Show the cast this replies to

Speaking as someone also sympathetic to the principle of network states, Balaji objectively missed an opportunity here. Had the acquisition happened the same way that Neynar's did, i.e., start off by maintaining the status quo and then roll out torward-looking rules, we could have enjoyed spirited but healthy discussions about techno democracies. But starting off with mass OG bans is analogous toNS moving into Forest City by evicting its residents. There's no scenario where this results in a positive sum outcome. A few people appealed and got back into the FC client, and even for those, the process of having to beg permission must have been whiplash-inducing given the crypto promise. Most people won't appeal though, and now the splinter is real, not just at the client level (for now) but also at the protocol level (soon). Multiple "network states" with different ethos can indeed emerge and coexist, but that doesn't mean we have to achieve that by aggravating each other. This is just vindicative tribalism.

11 likes5 recasts1 replies

1 reply

  • And if this was indeed all a mistake caused by the negligent deployment of a fumble-fingered AI with zero contextual awareness, then let Balaji come out and say it, make amends, and rebuild bridges. There ought to be massive overlap between the FC crowd and the broad spirit of NS (builders, techno optimists, etc). Such a wasted opportunity to be aggravating this NS-adjacent audience. I signed the smart contract because it was the only way I could get back to even the feature set I was enjoying for four years straight. I could have lived with it, or at least have listened to the arguments in favor. But when I found out later that half of my friends here got banned for really nonsensical reasons, I could no longer get behind this acquisition. Unfortunately I’m done with both FC (the client, and soon the protocol) and NS too.

    12 likes · 2 recastsRead 5 replies

    Well said. Sad to see you go. Still around Singapore for a few more weeks if you want to meet up.

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Thanks! I’ll still be casting, just from alt clients (Quorum for now). Once the Hypersnap chain fork happens, my casts won’t be visible to the Farcaster client users, and probably vice versa at some point if the NS team disables relaying. Yes, let’s catch up IRL soon — traveling this coming week but in SG the week after!

    4 likes · 0 recastsRead 2 replies

    Exactly. This transition was done in a moronic fashion and I think most of those who got the ban hammer were booted because NS doesn't agree with them and doesn't want them around.

    3 likes · 0 recasts

    See you later, den mate. Wish you the best. And thanks for giving it a shot 🎩

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    You, specifically, getting banned was a big driver in my decision that the current flavor of FC is not where I want to be. See you on the Hypersnap side of life!

    1 like · 0 recasts

    So I’m never going to see you again?

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    What a relief, eh? 😅 Nah, I’ll keep casting (though perhaps with less gusto), but I’ll use Quorum and the forked chain once available, so technically neither Farcaster the client nor the protocol. Though Quorum is not yet at feature parity and is still a bit rough around the edges, so I won’t be a purist about it until the stack improves

    3 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Where can we find you now?

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Still here my friend, just will be casting from alt clients (Quorum et al.) and hopefully that remains visible to those who prefer to stay on the official Farcaster client

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 2 replies