Cast by six

Show the cast this replies to

Trading and investing are not inherently more or less zero sum than the other. *Markets* can be varying degrees of zero to positive sum and those markets are always inclusive of both short term traders and long term investors. e.g. Bitcoin is a zero sum market that was plagued with short term investors until over time it became enough of a schelling point to attract long term investors. But still zero sum. The main problem here is not about the interfaces imo (eg nobody actually uses the Pump app for deploying or trading) it’s that there just aren’t many investable assets in crypto so the market has converged around assets that are ephemeral by design and closer to a video game than the stock market - because this is what players have revealed themselves to enjoy playing and also what regulatory uncertainty has incentivized. The market finds fair prices regardless of the behavior or time horizon of its participants.

0 likes0 recasts1 replies

1 reply

  • This is the reason I disliked majoring in Economics: Profits are not the only types of value being summed in these equations. Hyper short term assets require active management (see the many memes of trenchers showing themselves as worn-down individuals). This experience is typically a *cost* to a normal person. Investing does not include this cost to the extent trading does. Second, when an asset you hold produces external value beyond just the profit you get from it, that can provide the value of being part of something. Especially when it is an early stage company. Eg, imagine if you had been owning uber while being one of its first users. You are spreading something into the world, which you also believe is a good thing, which is a positive experience. There was an element of this to Higher, cryptopunks too, it's there is for bracky, so it's not just about "utility or not". But this sort of nonmonetary positive value begins to disappear the more pointless and pvp a given asset is.

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    I'm talking about the assets and markets not the trading behavior though? I agree with you on the unique active management cost of short term trading. But I don't think that applies to what I mentioned it's just a different vector. I'm not equating "investable" to "utility or not", I agree everything from memes to cultural schelling points to whatever you want to call it can be investable. Bitcoin and all the assets you mention are all assets I would call investable. I still would maintain there are not many investable assets in crypto and that is more of the issue than the trading interface. I agree that short term assets require active management which is why I equated them to a video game that requires participation. Most people shouldn't be participating in this game. IMO everything you've said is compatible with everything I've said.

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 2 replies

    By the way I don't disagree that an app can incentivize short term trading, I'm saying that this should be mostly irrelevant to whether a long-term minded asset should succeed long term. Capital finds a way to price assets fairly

    No likes or recasts yetRead 1 reply

    Yes, agree there's not many investable assets in crypto. What I think Maretus is expressing is that if interfaces continue to "play down" to the types of assets that exist, not having investable assets will become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Base aspired to "better" (not in a condescending way, but in a public-spirted way). I personally think they still do, but the trading focus seems like a departure for some of us who were excited about a better future for crypto. I'm optimistic, I just want to do justice to the spirit of Maretus's post, who is putting his money where his mouth is in a big way in supporting things that he believes in. Sounds like we are all in agreement there, but having differing opinions on how to navigate the current reality of crypto.

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply