Cast by vrypan.eth
Normie friend on vibe coding. Context: Has studied engineering, used to be b2b software pre-sales, has his own retail business now. Likes to fiddle with SQL and Excel macros, and a couple of lines of code copy-pasted from here and there, but he's no developer. - About a month ago: "Software developers are done, LLMs will do everything". - Yesterday: "I downloaded Cursor. Dude, we are so far from AGI, wtf is it doing!" On a more serious side, he said it's extremely empowering because he has been able to put together a proof of concept without a developer. But if he decides to go ahead with is, he will ask the AI to describe what the code does, and create a detailed project spec and give it to a developer. "And the developer will feed it to an AI", he laughed. He's probably right, but the dev will also add the technical details that he can't describe or is not even aware of: "use this framework, break these parts in modules, create a binary tree for this structure, add a message queue there, use the browser local storage this way, cache these values using a kv-store using a key created like this, etc."
16 replies
i'm similar to your normie friend, is this friend gonna continue using cursor?
Oh, yes. I think it's like this: Can I use an AI to design my dream car? Yes. Will I put my daughter in it? No, I'll give the design specs to a real engineer and let him build it.
agree with this, people can vibe code to build an app but to build a scalable app the ai agent still need some technical pointers from SE
I love cursor even over Claude code just for the messy and chaotic emergent process I’m able to get going with it
There's a difference btw a developer using AI to vibe code and someone with no prior knowledge about coding. If it's a html file.. no much issue But it gets tricky when we have to employ react.js, frameworks and some interactive UIs
I used claude code to write a fairly complex application but i am an experienced dev and i reviewed every step with plenty of interventions
Is this why I’m having a troubleshooting circle jerk just using ai to html and js code a damn static page?😵💫
Yes I can relate to that. The question is though how long until AI can do the full dev work flawlessly fron poc to production. Will it take more than 24 months??
Instead of getting stuck on C++/Java you are not stuck with English/Natural Language. That's one way of looking at it.