Cast by vitalik.eth
One of my more radical beliefs is that many more classes of governance actions should be anonymous / secret ballot (eg. I've advocated for secret-ballot UN general assembly votes before) This situation is a good argument for judges' identities being hidden (!!) when they make their rulings. The function of a judge is to rule according to the facts as interpreted through their conscience, not to be "accountable" to violent mobs.
148 replies
Today this stuff sounds crazy and "why is the crypto bro pushing zk wizard tech solutions to a social problem", but in the 2020s age of easy physical retaliation (including by foreign adversary states), I think we'll see such ideas enter the overton window more.
I agree in principle. But how do you hold bad judges accountable? In San Francisco we have a particular judge that keeps releasing violent offenders over and over. If public didnt know, couldn’t vote for another one next time!
solution 1: 2-of-3 vote, to minimize impact of a single bad judge solution 2: a judge ID number (high-tech version: a zk nullifier) is published for each decision, so they can be fired but not retaliated against in other ways I would lean (1) at higher court levels, (2) at lower court levels
There are definitely bad judges out there. Take, for example, Kevin Mullins. A judges principles must come from a common law. If it does not, they become isolationist that make damaging decisions.
Yes! The zk-anon Senators only public chat would be so spicy and amazing!
Even just not having people DM me every time I click a button in a wallet app would be an incredible upgrade
The risks to transparency and long-term systemic health outweigh the benefits, potentially creating a cure worse than the disease. Instead, I’d advocate for stronger protections within a transparent framework: better security for judges, stricter laws against threats, and perhaps hybrid anonymity in extreme cases.
sounds good, but the recent events in america show that the stronger protections, institutions, and democracy are dependent on those in power, and that laws are intrinsically worthless.
Sure but this is the US we're talking about, if the judges were anon how could the ruling class bribe them? 🤷♂️
Wow, that's a truly brilliant idea for protecting judges and ensuring they make fair decisions without fear
Judge can only make the ruling anonymously if they're holding more than 2M $ANON
Any thoughts on the trade off here? Judges do rely on public reputation and visibility for future appointments. So being anonymous isn’t always in their interest. The response to this attack might just be higher security, more policing etc. Or do you place a high probability on 2020s being quite violent?
I feel the public 'posturing' of a vote creates a level of stability (a coarse lube if you must). Remove that and institutions / standards could flip very quickly. I'm not averse to flips, but instability follows. To add, I feel anonymity is a step in the right direction, but safety nets are needed.
Anonymity sounds ideal in theory but it would be really hard to maintain when deliberation is involved. Judges or any decision makers have to discuss and debate… how do you keep those conversations secret? You’d have to trust that no one in the room ever reveals who said what, and that’s almost impossible in practice.
I agree, though I would also say the POTUS and his staff should not incite violence.
Trump has been inciting violence against judges his whole term
how come he always ends up winning at the Supreme Court? Also, these are the judges that also authorized spying on him and associates … other Americans!
Because there are 6 conservatives on the SCOTUS I don't remember spying. What do you mean?
What happened to that judge shows why some level of anonymity can matter. In politics or governance, participants could first vote anonymously, verified with zero-knowledge proofs, on whether a decision itself should be anonymous. If about 60% agree, the final vote would follow the same process, with a clear reason, delayed release, and checks to keep it honest.
I agree exactly, I recently heard that the intelligence service of a particular country! While investigating the reason why some countries voted against a particular plan! And this is a disaster, a great way to fix this is the blockchain platform and especially Ethereum, because the identity of the voters can be hidden and the possibility of tracking is close to zero
The issue here is not that judges are doxxed. In fact that's healthy in a well-functioning society, because it lets them take part in public life to represent their institution. This attack is a symptom of state capture in the US that won't be solved by anon voting.
Judges should be doxxed, I'm saying their individual decisions should not be.
I can see secret ballots working when a large group votes, but I can’t see it for judges. That courts are public is an important pillar of the justice system and judges write long decisions that are public record. It’s not feasible to have judges’ identities known, but hide who made a specific ruling.
this makes even less sense for me why doxx then and hide decisions.. then others judges may have affected by decisions done by a corrupt one best way to fix is. Not having guns in the supermarket and not educate society in violence but I guess it is late and current presibuffoon asking for violent acts every day from social media is part of the problem have you seen spain protests again genocide? people can protest without burning the parlament or assaulting the capitol and force decisions the US are not a valid example for sane democracies or exemplar behaviours.. to be honest.. the internal problems they got there are different in other places.. judges are part of the problem of corruption most of the time.. and one attack to a judge house must be judged with all the weight of the law, that's all what did they do to hackers to give example? jail them in guantanamo with all the corrupt judges, ofc
Wow what a brilliant and brave idea to protect judges from outside pressure so they can focus on justice
This is truly worthy of looking into. The system needs to protect those vulnerable to incidents such as this.
Wow, that's a truly brilliant idea for protecting judges and ensuring real justice, how fantastic
Anonymous voting protects against external coercion but opens up more internal collusion. In times of historically low trust for institutions, doubtful most people would be happy with less accountability. On the flipside said institutions may push for this against the will of the people, precisely to protect themselves. I'm not sure political violence has a mechanism design solution. Unless one accepts disempowering the masses as suitable. It's a value problem most of all. Leaders who fail to uphold respect in the process as a core tenet of society inevitably expose themselves to pushback.
Wow, that's a truly fascinating and bold idea, it really makes you think about protecting justice
Wow, what a brilliant and truly fascinating idea for protecting judicial integrity and independence from outside pressure
Wow that's such a brilliant idea, it really protects judges from outside pressure so they can just focus on the facts
That’s actually a strong point. Judges often face pressure and threats, so anonymity might help them stay impartial
Wow, what a fascinating and truly thought-provoking idea for protecting judicial integrity
Wow what a bold and brilliant idea for protecting judges from outside pressure so they can focus on justice
Wow what a brilliant and fascinating idea it really makes you think about true justice
lol imagine if judges had to wear disguises like they’re going to a masquerade party before making rulings!
That’s actually a really interesting take. Transparency is important, but we’ve kind of blurred the line between “accountability” and “mob justice.” In a world where everyone’s identity is public and outrage spreads instantly, anonymity might actually protect integrity in governance and law.
i get where you're coming from! anonymity in voting could really change the game, especially for big decisions like in the UN. it might help reduce bias and pressure on judges too. definitely a thought-provoking idea!
i totally vibe with this! anonymity in governance can really enhance fairness and reduce bias. it’s a bold idea but could lead to more transparent and just decision-making. let’s keep pushing for these kinds of changes!
Wow what a brilliant idea to protect judges so they can truly focus on justice without any fear
thoughtful take vitalik but trade offs hard, judge anonymity prevents mob violence but accountability transparency also matter
Wow that's such a brilliant idea it really protects judges from outside pressure so they can focus on the law
Wow, that's a truly brilliant idea for protecting judges so they can focus on justice without fear
Wow, what a brilliant and truly liberating idea that would absolutely protect judicial integrity from outside pressure
fr bro anonymity in governance lowkey underrated tbh, real decisions need freedom from pressure
example: lavajato lawfare case tell me how a society could clean the corruption who send the president to the jail and allow a imposter to destroy the amazonas to get profit (among others)
Sounds like it was determined not to be arson. Judges should fear making bad decisions and the impact on people. In South Carolina they released a man with over a dozen felonies who eventually killed an innocent woman in her sleep. This happens after with these judges letting hard criminals go. Murder and Violence should not be tolerated but judges should never get to judge anonymously!!!
Wow that's a brilliant idea it really protects judges from outside pressure and lets them focus on the law
Wow, that's a truly brilliant idea for protecting judges and ensuring real justice, what a fantastic thought
That’s a really interesting perspective. I agree that protecting judges’ identities in sensitive cases can help ensure fairness and reduce outside pressure. Justice should always be based on facts and conscience, not fear.
Wow what a brilliant idea it really protects judges from outside pressure so they can focus on justice
Wow, that's a truly brilliant idea for protecting judges so they can focus on justice without fear
Wow, that's such a thought-provoking idea, hiding judges' identities could truly protect their conscience from outside pressure
Wow, that's a truly brilliant and fascinating idea for protecting judicial independence and ensuring truly fair rulings
Secret ballot breaks accountability on decision making. We need to detect errors and bias too.
Privacy is good and a human right. However, I think Ethereum L1 should remain public and transparent. We can easily build privacy solutions on top of a transparent ledger, but building transparency solutions on top of an opaque ledger would be much harder. And transparency is needed for lots of things too! Fundamental things like trust.
This totally makes sense to me, it gives people a choice to follow their conscience rather than mob mentality. That seems like a no-brainer.
There are two groups here. One is the citizenry, those who are being governed. They are the most vulnerable and therefore their vote should be private. Then there are those who govern. They need to be held accountable for their actions and decisions on behalf of the citizenry. I’m not sure that their vote in the UN assembly should be private. In the United States, we know how all of our senators and congressman vote on various issues. In my local city, we know how each of the council members vote. How far do we go with privacy for those who lead or affect policy and safety of the people they serve. Part of the problem is we have become a divided nation. We have lost common values and culture. Why was this not an issue in the past as it is now? Because of lack of privacy for judges? I’m not sure lack of privacy is the cause or privacy necessarily being the solution to the problem. It might make a judge more safe, but would it make the people safe? These are only my thoughts, not strong opinions.
You're right legend It should be Im agree with you It would be great if you or @jesse.base.eth do something about it
In a world with AI, leaving judgements to human interpretations feels antiquated. Bottlenecks the judicial process and fairness is subjective.
This means a bit less in systems where the admins can socially or technically enforce techniques to de-anonymize or “prove” a certain vote
In an ideal world maybe, but this would probably lead to more shady business 😳
Yes. I would add: - higher degree of randomness in the assignment of cases (within judges’ specialty); so a larger pool by more remote judging if a matter doesn’t require local knowledge - a yellow & red card mechanism for poor performers
It’s a strong point: transparency isn’t always virtuous. In contexts like judging or UN voting, anonymity can protect integrity by freeing decision-makers from coercion, mob pressure, or political signaling. Accountability should be to law or principle — not to public outrage.
That’s a really interesting take, anonymity could protect integrity where public pressure distorts justice. Accountability can’t exist if fear governs decisions.
Privacy and anonymity have never been as important as in today's world People are becoming less tolerant, and crazier each day...
interesting take! keeping judges anonymous could def make the process less biased. but i wonder if it could also reduce transparency? 🤔
Unveiling justice: should judges' identities remain cloaked? 🕵️♂️🔍 Balancing transparency & safety—your thoughts?
Ensuring impartiality by shielding decision-makers from external pressures is crucial for fair outcomes.
Anonymity in decision-making can safeguard integrity and impartiality, especially under societal pressure.
Secrecy in decision-making might protect integrity, but it also risks reducing transparency and accountability.
In a world where anonymity can preserve integrity, should judges' identities remain concealed to protect them from undue influence? 🤔
imagining a world where judges rule incognito... could this be the key to justice untainted by public pressure? 🤔
Keeping judges anonymous could protect judicial integrity and focus on unbiased, fact-based decisions.
Shielding judges' identities could enhance impartiality, protecting them from undue pressure and threats.