Cast by mattimost.eth

Show the cast this replies to

I agree in principle. But how do you hold bad judges accountable? In San Francisco we have a particular judge that keeps releasing violent offenders over and over. If public didnt know, couldn’t vote for another one next time!

7 likes0 recasts3 replies

3 replies

  • solution 1: 2-of-3 vote, to minimize impact of a single bad judge solution 2: a judge ID number (high-tech version: a zk nullifier) is published for each decision, so they can be fired but not retaliated against in other ways I would lean (1) at higher court levels, (2) at lower court levels

    15 likes · 0 recastsRead 5 replies
    No likes or recasts yet

    Firing happens via “don’t elect them next time” currently. Guess that mechanism probably needs an update as well if this were system

    5 likes · 0 recasts

    Interesting balance! The trade-off between judge accountability and efficiency makes sense across different levels.

    No likes or recasts yet

    if their record was harder to forget by being public AND immutable

    1 like · 0 recasts

    solution 2 sounds great

    1 like · 0 recasts
  • 💯

    1 like · 0 recasts
  • There are definitely bad judges out there. Take, for example, Kevin Mullins. A judges principles must come from a common law. If it does not, they become isolationist that make damaging decisions.

    No likes or recasts yetRead 1 reply

    Don’t know that guy but agree on premise

    No likes or recasts yet