Cast by mattimost.eth
Show the cast this replies toI agree in principle. But how do you hold bad judges accountable? In San Francisco we have a particular judge that keeps releasing violent offenders over and over. If public didnt know, couldn’t vote for another one next time!
3 replies
solution 1: 2-of-3 vote, to minimize impact of a single bad judge solution 2: a judge ID number (high-tech version: a zk nullifier) is published for each decision, so they can be fired but not retaliated against in other ways I would lean (1) at higher court levels, (2) at lower court levels
Firing happens via “don’t elect them next time” currently. Guess that mechanism probably needs an update as well if this were system
Interesting balance! The trade-off between judge accountability and efficiency makes sense across different levels.
There are definitely bad judges out there. Take, for example, Kevin Mullins. A judges principles must come from a common law. If it does not, they become isolationist that make damaging decisions.