Cast by dwr

Show the cast this replies to

So if you're argument is Farcaster is not sufficiently "decentralized" (or "decentralized" if you don't like the sufficient framing) then you're defining decentralization as a protocol or network that has at least 2 independent, roughly equivalent functionality and UX clients (because majority of consumers revealed preference is UX over principles). That's a reasonable definition. But in practice, in the near-term, there's unlikely to be multiple, well-resourced enough clients that are full-time building on the protocol for amazing UX. That's not a knock on people building, just the reality that in 2024 consumers expect a lot of our their daily driver apps. In the medium to long-term, dedicated individuals, small teams or open source projects can likely hit the UX bar. But that will probably take years of sustained effort. So protocols in the early days are unlikely to hit the bar of 2 independent, roughly equivalent and functionality UX clients. This is something I've changed my mind on over the years.

14 likes1 recasts3 replies

3 replies

  • "But if Warpcast didn't have exclusivity on DCs and channels, then other clients could better compete" Yes, but having both be interoperable / in the protocol doesn't magically mean all of that surface area gets built out in other clients. I would assume other clients can move quicker by copying whatever patterns Warpcast has iterated to (avoiding all of our mistakes) and then in some cases, improve the UX. But building out a robust chat UX in 2024 that's passable (not even Telegram level snappy) is *a lot* of work. That's effort not being spent on differentiating features or other core parts of the app. Same goes for channels. And arguably, the most important part of a feed-based social app is the feed, which is mostly backend (machine learning, performance). One advantage for other clients are dedicated infrastructure companies like @neynar, @openrank etc. But it's still a lot of work.

    11 likes · 0 recastsRead 3 replies

    To close: it's easy to have a bunch of opinions on how the ecosystem should be built. But if you talk to the people building the apps, they often have a different perspective having been in the salt mines. That's not to say we are doing everything perfectly (we're not!) and we don't make mistakes. One of the reasons we are holding Developer Day next week is to get candid feedback from a group of developers working in the ecosystem daily. Goal is to get everyone better aligned and rowing in the same direction to make Farcaster successful.

    14 likes · 0 recastsRead 3 replies

    appreciate the write up... so whats the end vision for warpcast/farcaster or are we just stayin flexible

    No likes or recasts yetRead 1 reply

    Great move reaching out to dev’s here build here daily. fwiw it feels like you aren’t listening to your daily users and implement changes only to hear the cacophony afterwards. I realize you can’t respond to every opinion flying at you daily but a panel of community experts Ala Moxie could refine the suggestions to something tangible.

    No likes or recasts yet

    Every time you do one of these threads, it's a little more satisfying. Keep it up! Would like to hear how you think about a world where Warpcast is open source (not necessarily accepting outside contributors, but allowing people to quickly fork and bootstrap their own variants with minor changes). Not guaranteed but might make a dent in the multiple clients dimension.

    No likes or recasts yetRead 1 reply

    def believe it’s a lot of work, but it’s a big yes to that 1st question as well making the most used features of a social network avaliable to every builder to use or not should be a priority, no? i mean, i’d think that if the protocol is what matters the most. as user, i want to be on farcaster, but i dont like being on warpcast.

    No likes or recasts yet

    I do think channels need to be decentralized asap. To me the feature is a key part of what makes farcaster a unique experience compared to twitter, and having only warpcast support it is a big tax on the viability of alt clients.

    7 likes · 0 recastsRead 5 replies

    We are doing everything to announce your family cat $MASYA. We really need one thing, can you help us with liqudity? We have been here for 2 years, we are always with you 0x26f45C6D6bfdd89d37a8856838c2141348334E0F

    No likes or recasts yet

    I know you will hear my voice. Would you donate the MASYA in your wallet to charity? Or create liquidity for us?

    No likes or recasts yet

    Channel content has been decentralized since Day 1. So they have worked on other clients from a read / write content standpoint. Just haven’t figured out the fight form factor for metadata (a year of failed iteration on our part). We’re optimistic that the membership change will work and then we have a clear path to decentralization long creation, metadata, etc.

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Is this cat cute than you?

    No likes or recasts yet

    Read/write is open but we’re still figuring out moderation. Hopeful that this iteration is good enough to finalize on and commit to the protocol.

    3 likes · 0 recasts
  • intredasting.. ⚡️

    No likes or recasts yet
  • thoughtful breakdown. do you think that this bar would be more likely to be hit if warpcast was open-source?

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Good question. I'm going to quote cast to respond more publicly.

    1 like · 0 recasts