Cast by kyb
Show the cast this replies toLooked the post up on the node. 10 likes on the node: symbiotech, Karsa, Arjan, KMac, Njal, Lish, Jerry-d, muyang, cassie, catfacts 8 likes in NS data: the same list without cassie and catfacts. Both are banned on NS. 4 in the NS app list you saw: symbiotech, Karsa, KMac, Njal. KMac and Njal are not opted in. 2 in your NS notification: symbiotech, Karsa. Both opted in. Notably Arjan is opted in but not on this list or the previous. Opt in status of all on NS: Opted in: symbiotech, Karsa, Arjan Not opted in: KMac, Njal, Lish, Jerry-d, muyang Banned: cassie, catfacts So they are completely removing people with the ban. Then adding an additional filter ontop of it. Basically a shadowban.
5 replies
cc @arjantupan you might be interested in possibly being shadowbanned. On some posts
You're saying I am shadowbanned on some posts? Hmm, I can't think of how that would work, though I have noticed I never see @purp 's posts in my feed these days and I talk to him most days.
@arjantupan is getting shadowbanned. And the rest are getting filtered out because they’re not opted in. Thats the discrepancy in the numbers. You’re not shadowbanned because you’re already opted out. And what kind of feed are you using? If you’re on a follow feed, which most of the alt clients use as default. They have reply bumping. And you’re following alot of people. So his top level posts are probably getting buried in the follow feeds.
Firefly sucks since the fork, its a day behind on notifications
Yep, I realised that would be the case. Ever since I quote casted @kenjiquest's bunker scene video. I got a dm with a very nice message about it and realised it would result in a shadow ban. Which is fine. Couldn't care less, tbh. But they will have to ban me to get me off-platform.
Sorry that was the symptom of reacting to the vid. They told you in a DM it would be a shadow ban? Would explain why others withdrew their comment/reply if they are getting threatened with repercussions for engagement.
This is how NS treats people even if they opt in but say anything contrarian to their narrative even just once without even a warning. Even if it doesn’t break any of the rules, isn’t rude, inciting fights or creating animosity. And that was just for engaging with my post and not being the post originator at all. NS Farcaster is slowly encroaching on any free will to say anything critical and is showing their hand in wanting to groom a group of sycophants or zealots who will just do as they are told, by learning what they are told is good (via the book club + $’s) and flash a loosely veiled threat of shadow banning for the disobedient without saying the quiet parts out loud. If this isn’t the case, then they should release Arjan’s shadow ban to prove their point. I doubt that will happen, but it would be cool if they did that just out of spite. @adrienne While this isn’t your problem, I think seeing things for what they are is probably worth its while for you given your podcast is about bringing up news about Farcaster. Including inconvenient truths. I do understand though, if the very life of the podcast hangs in the balance to appease the new owners, then I guess I can’t really be critical of a desire to survive under new management, because the cut to engagement will come swiftly if they choose to filter you out. It’s ironic though, the “bug” that occurred to my account which resulted in a filtering or shadow banning of my account right at the same timing as when the Bunker video was released, really just is proving my point in the video. I hope the irony of that is not going unnoticed.
They won’t be able to thread this needle. They can’t have an open, opinionated internet community that is also comfortable with variable and sometimes-hidden censorship. An authoritarian society appears orderly because disorder is hidden, not just because people are complicit. Humans make messes and have impure thoughts. You can’t stop it. You can only try to hide it. And people will take the wrong lesson. Conversation on their platform will drift towards a state-aligned center; everything else will stop being made or will be actively hidden. A closed network in most respects; the doors are open, but no one will walk through.
Acknowledged. I think you guys aren’t going to like my personal view on this. A lot of the criticism and accusations I’ve been hearing would be totally valid under merkles reign bc of what we understood what they wanted to build- sufficiently decentralized social network. Balajis has a different vision, and I don’t think we know yet what that will look like. I’m not saying your wrong to be upset about perceived censorship (but also the whole point of having a protocol with multiple clients is clients are free to do whatever they want and people are free to move), but the energy spent being upset is wasted energy bc it’s based on old assumptions about farcaster being a protocol for social network and not what I think will be a protocol for network societies. But again, too early to know so I’m still in wait and see, before judging. Don’t mean to discount or blow off your feelings or thoughts, and thank you for the ping, and I appreciate you always 🫡 💜
So you're opted in but shadowbanned as well you're saying?
@cryptonjal tipped McHypersnap (McWarp's NFTs) to @kenjiquest! 278 artworks left to tip
Nice work. A two layered filtering method makes sense here. Good to know!