Cast by kellphone

Show the cast this replies to

Spotify API gives you access to every single song. You can build your own algorithm on top of that (see similar boppers here bopping.to/@tom__kell). OP @drewcoffman.eth is chatting about "sharing" which is a intentional thing right? No need for data when it's "I know who would like this" and posting "if you like this you'll like this"

1 likes0 recasts1 replies

1 reply

  • Yeah but obviously that's not working. That's the whole premise of an open protocol (and Blockchains, tbh). It's something to build on top of. Look at Farcaster. Anyone can build on it and access the data of the social graph. Look at Warpcast and frames: now devs can access the social graph and get distribution instantly by throwing up a frame. Massively exponentiating the amount of experimentation compared to what is happening on Facebook or Twitter. Spotify keeps their social graph secret, so anyone building on the API has to create their own social graph of data. That's what a walled garden is. To the OP's point: sharing a link to a song or playlist isn't innovative or fun. That's the whole point. We could be doing incredible things with custom AI tuning and autonomous collaborating across a composable social graph if Spotify empowered users to have data sovereignty.

    No likes or recasts yetRead 1 reply

    I'm all for that, we've done a load of blockchain building with @supercollector (I think data on what you *really* love is more valuable that what you might have put on in the background). Real talk is that Spotify aren't going to give up what they monetise, just not going to happen, I'd love it to, but it won't, but I also think that it mostly powers lean-back auto-play stuff that causes a certain amount of apathy towards music listening. Me knowing all your listening data is not so valuable to me, me knowing how our data overlaps can make guesses to what I might enjoy but the pro-active *sharing* of music using existing established social platforms is my take on what the OP thinks could be explored more - and kinda more healthy for music culture?? Either way it's a real challenge that hasn't been cracked.. yet

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 2 replies

    Yeah I agree, Spotify won't lead the way. Was just using that as an "imagine this" for easy context. Opportunity for someone new to prove the value of the use-case! Either Spotify catches on and follows suit, or gets left behind as another Blockbuster. I think all the problems you describe with Spotify are a result of stagnant experimentation in the space caused by walled gardens. Yes, better social tools for sharing are an uncracked nut. I blame it on lack of opportunity & incentive for experimentation due to the rent seeking of a closed social graph. We peaked at the mix-tape and haven't innovated since. New user behaviors are erupting left and right on Farcaster due to it offering space for this experimentation. Music will be the same once a composable social graph is available!

    1 like · 0 recasts

    Glad to see you're innovating in the space, I'll check it out and see what you got cooking!

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply