Cast by kenjiquest
Show the cast this replies toThis is how NS treats people even if they opt in but say anything contrarian to their narrative even just once without even a warning. Even if it doesn’t break any of the rules, isn’t rude, inciting fights or creating animosity. And that was just for engaging with my post and not being the post originator at all. NS Farcaster is slowly encroaching on any free will to say anything critical and is showing their hand in wanting to groom a group of sycophants or zealots who will just do as they are told, by learning what they are told is good (via the book club + $’s) and flash a loosely veiled threat of shadow banning for the disobedient without saying the quiet parts out loud. If this isn’t the case, then they should release Arjan’s shadow ban to prove their point. I doubt that will happen, but it would be cool if they did that just out of spite. @adrienne While this isn’t your problem, I think seeing things for what they are is probably worth its while for you given your podcast is about bringing up news about Farcaster. Including inconvenient truths. I do understand though, if the very life of the podcast hangs in the balance to appease the new owners, then I guess I can’t really be critical of a desire to survive under new management, because the cut to engagement will come swiftly if they choose to filter you out. It’s ironic though, the “bug” that occurred to my account which resulted in a filtering or shadow banning of my account right at the same timing as when the Bunker video was released, really just is proving my point in the video. I hope the irony of that is not going unnoticed.
4 replies
They won’t be able to thread this needle. They can’t have an open, opinionated internet community that is also comfortable with variable and sometimes-hidden censorship. An authoritarian society appears orderly because disorder is hidden, not just because people are complicit. Humans make messes and have impure thoughts. You can’t stop it. You can only try to hide it. And people will take the wrong lesson. Conversation on their platform will drift towards a state-aligned center; everything else will stop being made or will be actively hidden. A closed network in most respects; the doors are open, but no one will walk through.
Acknowledged. I think you guys aren’t going to like my personal view on this. A lot of the criticism and accusations I’ve been hearing would be totally valid under merkles reign bc of what we understood what they wanted to build- sufficiently decentralized social network. Balajis has a different vision, and I don’t think we know yet what that will look like. I’m not saying your wrong to be upset about perceived censorship (but also the whole point of having a protocol with multiple clients is clients are free to do whatever they want and people are free to move), but the energy spent being upset is wasted energy bc it’s based on old assumptions about farcaster being a protocol for social network and not what I think will be a protocol for network societies. But again, too early to know so I’m still in wait and see, before judging. Don’t mean to discount or blow off your feelings or thoughts, and thank you for the ping, and I appreciate you always 🫡 💜
How do you view the differences between a protocol for social network and a protocol for network societies. My biggest issue here is that we actually know what NS is going to look like. His book has been out awhile and his Malaysia/Kazakhstan application of the ideas in the book has been going a couple years. His ideology fits within a group of ideologies that tech oligarchs have been focused on for a lot longer than even the NS book has been out. He's just following a long established set of ideas to arrive at his own certain of it and then applying a playbook to create a world that plays by it.
Thanks Adrienne for the reply. I had an inkling that this may be the response after having read your most recent article this morning about your Buddhist experiences. I think the conclusion of the article being the main message you want to convey - the art of letting go. The message has a good life outlook message but feels very much more directed at what is happening here at Farcaster as a matter of perspective. I say this all in good faith. I guess the phrase “Farcaster is dead” is half true in that the Farcaster that we knew of (the permissionless social under merkle) is indeed dead, as it doesn’t seem like this is what NS wants to pursue. Both through its verbal and its actions. The FC network itself is still alive, so those who still want that part of Farcaster need to pick up the remnants of what’s left and rebuild again. And you’re right, some users need to let go and fully embrace their new home. Whether that’s living in the new NS eco or living on a protocol that better aligns with their values and lifestyle. I’m not angry or upset per se, but no one likes being gagged and hidden from their friends is all. So a desire to be heard and let people know, is a thing. You’re right, being upset and angry takes up a lot of energy and can be futile. But spreading awareness to those people who are clearly feeling bewildered but are unaware of their options is probably a good cause to speak up and let them know of what options or alternatives are available. My writing is getting pretty long so I’ll wrap it up, but I think if NS actually had thought through of a transition plan, things wouldn’t have been so bad. - We have acquired FC - We have no intention of being a permissionless social network - We are happy to champion alt clients and protocols to pursue this vision - These are the rules we look to put on place and will have a 1 month grace period Being up front about it would have been much better. Sure there still would have been haters, but at least everyone would have been informed.
When you say a "protocol that better aligns" with them, are you talking about Hypersnap as a protocol? I'm in the least technical group of people that have not opted in or have opted out, and I was assuming that the protocol is still Farcaster, both via Snapchain and Hypersnap, but that filtering is being done at the NS client level. So wouldn't the protocol still be the same as it was before, or are you talking about aligning with a protocol outside of Snapchain/Hypersnap entirely?
I definitly agree with you as far as speaking up still and hoping this either changes some minds or informs those who are unaware of things. I'm also in agreement as far as the way they should have done the takeover, assuming the same goals on their end but wanting less of an issue or to simply be polite and respectful of the people that were part of things during the Merkle/Neynar era.
That would imply there was no malice behind the actions. And maybe, for the majority of people who got hit with the ban, this is true, but the following things _are also_ true: - Neynar participated heavily in orchestrating the ban wave. - The rap sheet API exposed all of the "violations", including ones not shown in a user's ban reason list. - The ones explicitly not shown to me by UI, but were hidden in the API for the ban decision included every single cast where I was arguing with rish and manan, and included ones that a bot would not have picked up on, and were manually curated. - Access to features like DMs were locked out, and Rish personally DM'd me after the ban went out to let me know that he sent me an email, knowing full and well I would be unable to reply to it. In short, the ban may have largely been automated, but for the one building a credible alternative, I was _intentionally_ silenced, which says a lot.
@cryptonjal tipped McHypersnap (McWarp's NFTs) to @adrienne! 277 artworks left to tip
agree that Farcaster is mutating. agree that arguing otherwise is wasted energy. otherwise not persuaded by the tortured logic here, sorry. welcome to repeat “what they did was okay because [reasons]” ofc. I’m just not persuaded.
I'm not trying to persuade anyone to think a certain way. I'm sharing my thoughts for transparency. I generally aim to seek understanding and not necessarily agreement. I like to know what people think and why, and I like when people are free to draw their own conclusions. 🤷♀️
And you think that is due to a bug, not due to an issue with how the powers that be perceive that post?
@cryptonjal tipped McHypersnap (McWarp's NFTs) to @kenjiquest! 278 artworks left to tip