How I learned about the Buddhist concept of non-attachment

When I was young, maybe 14 or 15 years old, I went to my Uncle Burcha’s funeral.

Burcha wasn’t my real uncle. He was my grandfather’s “war buddy.” Together with their wives and young children, the two friends escaped communist Russia in the 1940s and came to America as refugees via Germany. That experience bonded them for life. So we called him Uncle.

And I’m not even sure it was technically a funeral I attended. It was a Buddhist service, and all I remember being told was that the purpose was to get Uncle Burcha’s spirit to leave his body and move on to the next stage of the afterlife. Whatever that stage is or was, I’m not totally clear on. But you get the point.

The room I entered was filled with folding chairs organized in neat rows. At the front were maybe six or eight monks in orange and burgundy robes, sitting cross legged in two rows facing each other, chanting in a language I didn’t understand (probably Tibetan).

I sat next to my sister about two-thirds of the way back. I wasn't feeling particularly sad about Burcha’s passing. To my adolescent brain, he was old and it was his time. I was being respectful, but mostly I just remember being bored. Unlike the Jewish funerals I had been to, where a rabbi speaks to the congregation and everyone participates in the service, here we were just observers, watching the monks do their thing. There wasn't much to do except look around the room. It was colorful, filled with prayer flags, tapestries, rugs, icons, and statues, but it wasn’t grand or ornate like the synagogues or churches I was familiar with.

At some point during the service, I started hearing crying from the front of the room. When I looked up, I saw it was coming from Uncle Burcha's wife. Her sobs grew louder and louder. Her body was shaking. I don’t remember anyone else in the room crying. Just her.

At my age, I hadn’t yet lost anyone I was very close with, and I wasn’t familiar with grief like that. I’d been to plenty of somber funerals for great aunts and uncles, but none of those deaths had felt particularly tragic to me. I was also raised to hold back tears and manage my emotions, so I distinctly remember feeling surprised to see a grown woman expressing raw grief.

After some time (ten minutes? fifteen minutes?), I saw people ushering my aunt out of the room. Were they taking her somewhere private to comfort her? Somewhere she could cry without everyone watching?

Nope!

My mom told me later that the monks had requested she leave because her loud cries were interfering with their work.

The monks had a job to do. They were praying to get Uncle Burcha’s soul to its next place. And her loud crying was holding him back and making their job more difficult.

In a Jewish funeral, we read the same prayers in the same order, and when it’s done, it’s done. But this Buddhist service had an objective. The monks had a job to do and only they knew when the job was done. Maybe it would take five minutes if his soul was ready to leave, or maybe they’d have to pray for hours until it happened. Or so I was told.

My aunt’s presence was preventing them from finishing their job. Her cries were like strings attached to his soul, holding him down to earth, keeping him attached to her. And the monks couldn’t complete their work.

So they asked her to leave.

HER! HIS WIFE! THE WOMAN WHO HAD FLED WAR WITH HIM AND ENDURED WHO KNOWS HOW MANY HARDSHIPS. THE WOMAN WHO HAD SPENT HER LIFE TOGETHER WITH HIM IN LOVE.

She was asked to leave her husband's funeral.

I remember that blew my mind and it was my first introduction to just how extreme the Buddhist concept of non-attachment can be.


A Note on My Memory

That’s the story as I remember it. While writing it down, I checked a few details with one of my aunts. It turns out I was probably 17 or 18, not 14 or 15, but she did confirm it was a funeral.


Letting Go

A core concept in Buddhist philosophy is the idea that attachment leads to suffering. We get attached to people, possessions, relationships, and expectations. We want things to stay the way they are. But nothing is permanent, and when things inevitably change, our unwillingness to let go causes us to suffer.

If we must eventually let go of even the people we love most in the world, what about all the other silly, stupid, or small things we get attached to?

Surely, we can practice letting go of some of them. And maybe we'll feel a little lighter for it.

39 likes11 recasts4 replies

4 replies

  • Thanks for sharing Adrienne. Was always fascinated by how different cultures approach death and mourning. In the religion of the book (Christianity, Judaism & Islam), particularly around Mediterranean Sea, people during funeral must express intensively pain of loss, pushed by presence of professional mourners. I dont see it as attachment, but it took be years to understand, a form of tribute to the deceased through expression of pain, crying and screaming. A collective and individual catharsis. In other animist religions (as I saw in West Africa), mourning is a joyful moment, people are happy to have known, shared moments with the deceased Buddhism see it as a state of non-attachment / detachment Different paradigms, fate, perceptions of what's visible and what's not visible

    2 likes · 0 recasts
  • Thank you for sharing this! I hope the others come to fruition as well because all of the topics sounded great!

    2 likes · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Well since you asked so nicely… I will try to find time to do the other two too 😁

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    ٩(^ᗜ^ )و ´-

    1 like · 0 recasts
  • Everything is impermanent. Be equanimous.

    No likes or recasts yet
  • Really one of THE best life lessons I ever learned (eventually at the tender age of 32 and the help of an amazing yoga teacher who told me about Donna Farhi’s book)

    2 likes · 0 recasts