Cast by balajis.eth
Outstanding piece by @0xstark.eth, one of the best I’ve read this year.
19 replies
Some thoughts. First, what he calls “programmable hardness” I’ve called “programmable scarcity”, as distinct from “programmable information.” That is, the internet lets you *copy* digital objects easily, but blockchains let you also *transfer* them — by using cryptography to create digital scarcity.
However, “programmable hardness” may be a better phrase. It combines several concepts under one umbrella: - financially hard, as in hard money - computationally hard, as in NP-hard - legally hard, as in hard commitment - practically hard, as in hard to fake And the visual is “physically hard” as in gold.
Programmable hardness is a generalization of the hard money that is Bitcoin. It pulls in many adjacent words: - scarcity - difficulty - constraint - commitment - immutable - uncensorable - fixed - permanent - archival - reliable - constant - dependable - trustworthy - transparent - provable - verifiable
This is how I used to explain PoW: Have you noticed how much work goes into printing a dollar bill? Special paper, spacial inks, hidden codes, etc. All this work proves to you that this is a genuine bill. It's the proof of work put into it, that builds trust. I wish I knew about hardness :-)
Yep I’ve said this many many times. But THIS is the greatest piece written on blockchains that I’ve ever read. Thank you @0xstark.eth
I haven’t always enjoyed your thinking but this ser has been an amazingly good read that works very well with my own concepts. Thank you for sharing!!
It is striking to me to see hardness and immediately have the thought that “softness” is what I wrote Formal Dialectics to call attention to and indeed have been fairly well obsessed with since college. Godel showed that math can be in fact quite soft (perhaps has a soft belly) and extrapolating has yielded…
something like a philosophy of language that accounts for softness. It is quite gratifying to see that others can engage with the flip side and that there are no contradictions between my work and this. Thank you @0xstark.eth
Find my current project, worldview ethics, which will result in a book late this year and which essentially details what we might call “moral hardness” (and softness!) onchain here:
One of the best ones for me, too. PS: Finally @kiwi hivemind has found a top essay faster than Balaji. warpcast.com/macbudkowski/0x010168
if you haven't read it yet @balajis.eth, I highly recommend this @vgr essay. It's imo the same tier as Josh's
Fantastic piece @0xstark.eth - extremely well written and the first thing I would share with anyone asking me why I am excited about- & building in the space!
Definitely a thought-provoking and intriguing read. That said, I'll still take "trustworthiness" over "hardness" and (variants of) "predictability" over "cast" any day, conceptual baggage and all.
Everything is built on expectedness. The more hardness or higher degree of expectedness, the stronger the system. In search of negentropy…
Also why programmers love pure functions.. no side effect functions make perfect building blocks