Cast by dwr
Show the cast this replies toI think it’s a reasonable request. But prioritizing the playing field and then not having anyone make a significant, long term investment in building is incorrect prioritization. There are virtually no sign ups from other clients and permissionless sign ups have been live for almost a year. Huge lift, no developer pay off. Developers overwhelmingly want us to get 100x more good users for the protocol before anything else.
4 replies
It's kind of a chicken and egg thing though isn't it? Probably don't have sign ups because currently they lack all the features. Currently, other clients are for power users, not "normies" IMO. I feel this would change if all things are equal IMO. But I get your point about it being a big, time consuming lift for you guys.
I don’t think permissionless channel creation (same argument as permissionless sign ups) drives usage since it’s a small % of people creating channels. DCs help, but they aren’t a reason to join the network. Telegram and Twitter already at scale for crypto people. So neither are the reasons people aren’t using other apps or Farcaster. Need differentiated features or content. Likely both.
Agree on channels. Fair point. DC's though aren't a reason to join, but they have definitely been a BIG reason (among others) for me to stay on Farcaster (which currently means Warpcast) to talk to the people daily I've met here. This is the reason I'm tied to Warpcast permanently. We've tried migrate to TG when DC's where in a rough state a while ago, but the flow for sharing casts etc in another app is horrible. Long story short, I do feel other clients pick up usage when DC's open up.
It makes no sense for a third party client to create a flow to sign up new users. They will inevitably have to set up Warpcast anyway to access the full featureset (for example for sign in with Warpcast) As a client developer, there are so many better things to work on, like for example differentiating features.
I think you are confused, sir. It is because many functions are controlled by Warpcast that third-party clients are not competitive and have to register with Warpcast. It is because of the monopoly that this situation occurs.
Another one question: has there been any substantial progress in Farcaster in the past 2024?
I'm facing an issue where mid-scale or established web2 companies want to enter web3, but they find it too focused on the crypto crowd, and they struggle to understand the terminology. Platforms like Twitter and Telegram have a strong crypto community, but web2 companies feel left out. Wouldn't creating an easy bridge for them to understand and transition to web3 could help increase sign-ups and activity?