Cast by six
Show the cast this replies tothe incentive (profit) is the same whether you are trading short term or investing long term. what does the exchange interface have to do with that? the same asset can have short term traders and long term investors. this is true across markets
3 replies
the incentive to hold an asset long term is if you believe in it long term "zero incentive to hold" suggests the participant doesn't believe in it long term enough to hold on to it. which is perfectly fine but that's an asset issue not a base app issue
Right because base is optimizing for “always something new to trade” rather than “we have these awesome long term projects you can invest in.” Why hold something long term if there’s always going to be a new token to trade? Can you point to a couple serious projects on base whose charts don’t look like complete ass?
This is true!! Bitcoin was held up and down for many years till it became a favorable “asset” many many years down the line But we also have to explain more the difference between creator coins and content coins.
I think what you’re missing is that an interface can obviously shape what kinds of things win in a market, hence shaping the incentive buyers think they have in that environment. For example: Pump’s chaotic interface was designed for the purpose of making it almost impossible to focus on anything except the latest thing that pops up. And the shitty design makes things feel inherently invaluable/pointless. These feelings incentivize quick buys and quick sells, since that’s the game you sense everyone is playing. On the other end of the spectrum, a TDA feels stable, lists extremely qualified names, has deep dives of information on every asset, etc. This feels like it incentivizes slow, careful action about things that are real. Or think of how powerful it is to be “verified” on the interfaces of OpenSea or fomo, and what that incentivizes for coordinated buying. I find the concern in this case especially valid (and everybody in Base orbit is so opinionated) bc the interface-asset dynamic is especially powerful here: the assumption is that the Base app’s structure will play an outsized role in the assets that thrive on Base chain. Now I personally am optimistic that Base is going to build something with a balance between things that feel interesting on a short term and long term horizon. But regardless it’s a positive thing if there are a growing number of people in crypto who want to be able to stop having the experience of flipping scam tokens and start having the experience of being a part of things that are worthy of believing in.
From my perspective, trading overwhelmingly favors sophisticated actors with capital, tools, resources, etc. like the snipers who take the majority of profit for most tokens launched. Trading a lot is the fastest way to go broke in crypto unless you are very very good at it like @remilioremo OR you’re also using the same tools. The current trajectory for Base is a lot of people churning because losing money does that to people. IMO, the best way for Base to grow would be to focus on investing rather than trading. Trading is totally 0 sum whereas investing isnt as much. If every chart on Base looks like a volatile pump and dump; we arent going to inspire a lot of confidence from normies and we probably wont see many new people entering these assets.
Trading and investing are not inherently more or less zero sum than the other. *Markets* can be varying degrees of zero to positive sum and those markets are always inclusive of both short term traders and long term investors. e.g. Bitcoin is a zero sum market that was plagued with short term investors until over time it became enough of a schelling point to attract long term investors. But still zero sum. The main problem here is not about the interfaces imo (eg nobody actually uses the Pump app for deploying or trading) it’s that there just aren’t many investable assets in crypto so the market has converged around assets that are ephemeral by design and closer to a video game than the stock market - because this is what players have revealed themselves to enjoy playing and also what regulatory uncertainty has incentivized. The market finds fair prices regardless of the behavior or time horizon of its participants.