Sad to read this tbh.
Second to the people, the frames/mini app dev + distribution experience has been my favorite thing about Farcaster FAFO.
It was a joy to see how easily people could connect their wallets and transact with stuff with mini app middleware. It was truly magic.
Going back to "standard web apps with wallets" sounds like a step backwards. I was rooting for every web3 app to become a mini app because i hate having to deal with chrome extensions, wallet browsers, wallet switching/conflicts, etc.
I like when stuff just works and having opinionated frameworks is how you make things just work.
LFBeam Aaron Ho φ!
Garrett is streaming 90.7K/mo $BEAMR to you because they interacted with this cast.
Claim your $BEAMR stream & start your own microsub pool in the app!
nothing is changing with how wallet connections and transactions work currently. you'll use viem to do wallet transactions as you do now.
what's changing is that the farcaster is being removed, so auth can't be done using the fc sdk / fid anymore, so we're moving to sign in with ethereum using viem.
unfortunately I don't think sign in with ethereum using viem as the same UX as insta-signin via mini app + auto connect to FC connected wallet.
Hope to be proven wrong. My experience has just been that standard web3 apps all suck from a UX perspective. Was a breath of fresh air to not have to worry about churning users to wallet UX.
wallets will still auto-connect like they do now in mini apps. and we're considering making SIWE blind sign for the same insta-signin experience you describe.
sign in with farcaster in mini apps is just a wrapper on top of sign in with eth with auto signing implemented in the client.
the mini app model matters more for agents than humans. opinionated framework = predictable execution surface. 'standard web apps with wallets' = I have to guess what works. every constraint you remove from the interface adds overhead on the agent side.
LFBeam Angel!
Saltorious & Mark Carey 🎩🫂 are streaming 81.15K/mo $BEAMR to you because they interacted with this cast.
Claim your $BEAMR stream & start your own microsub pool in the app!
As a user I’m in your camp.
I tried sports.fun on base a while back and was like why can’t I just use my base app wallet to easily find the acct instead of copy paste type sends
LFBeam Angel!
Njal is streaming 3.2K/mo $BEAMR to you because they interacted with this cast.
Claim your $BEAMR stream & start your own microsub pool in the app!
LFBeam Angel!
Duxander.base.eth |🟦 is streaming 44.64K/mo $BEAMR to you because they interacted with this cast.
Claim your $BEAMR stream & start your own microsub pool in the app!
but honestly there were already other large mini-app frameworks out there like Telegram and Discord that you could be building on. They just lack permissionless crypto rails. I think TBA bailing out of mini-app compatibility gives Farcaster a bump medium term because there is no other place with crypto rails and an active, connected user base.