Cast by patriciaxlee.eth
CONTROL BUTTONS REQUEST “I want to remove this user’s casts from my home feed.” and “I still want to see if they reply, tag, or send me a message.” Both of these are not simultaneously possible with the control buttons we currently have in Farcaster. // After experimenting and reading about them, here’s my understanding of our control buttons: > Block The blocked account cannot interact with me. I can’t see them and they can’t see me. > Mute The muted account can interact with me, but I won’t know it. They can’t see me but I can’t see them. I no longer see the account in my home feed - effective immediately. But I will also no longer see their replies under my own casts, which is a big step beyond what I need. Their own content may not be my cup of tea as I scroll. It doesn’t mean I want them to disappear completely from view. For that, I already have block. > Show fewer like this First described a year ago as a button not to over-think and simply provides information for the team to improve the overall algorithm. Then described more recently as needing improvement but that pressing 3x would function like mute. Pressing 3x seemed to work temporarily. But after experimenting thoroughly with this button recently, I find no amount of pressing it removes users from my home feed anymore. // In addition to my own frustrations over the current functionality, I also see many casts indicating other users feel similar lack of control over their feed lately. It’s also the #1 question/feedback from people I’ve recently invited to Farcaster. I believe lack of clarity around feed control is leading to unnecessary agitation over their experience scrolling, as well as with each other. Like a city that’s starting to feel overcrowded, Farcaster would benefit from enabling users get space from each other. I don’t want my neighbor to be eliminated off the face of the earth. I just don’t want them to be the first person I see in the morning when I walk down the street. What I would like to see: Block - No change Mute - Muted account does not appear in my Home feed, but replies and mentions are still visible (this is how X does it and is likely how most users interpret the word “mute”). Show fewer like this - I now believe this button should be removed or renamed. It is confusing if it does not have direct impact on user experience. If this is a necessary button for the team for overall algorithm improvement, I recommend renaming the button to something less action-oriented. “Show” implies action will be triggered, whereas “Not Interested” might be more appropriate as a statement of preference that may or may not have any effect. Would appreciate others to chime in if they are feeling similar frustrations or if they have a different POV.
27 replies
I agree with you!! Those buttons do wonders and help people find their own tribe imo
Do you feel they’ve helped you find your tribe here - if so, how? Teach me your ways :) Or you mean theoretically if they functioned properly?
I'm still gathering my tribe here, but it definitely helped me to get rid of accounts I don’t enjoy seeing (misogyny, racism, hatred). This has made my algorithm better. I also block fake or insincere accounts. I think I’ve muted only one person so far, and that was because their content was extremely repetitive. Once my boyfriend told me that we could design our own lives, and I really stand by that since it applies to everything. Wherever attention goes, energy flows. So why keep following an account that triggers you? same with other social media. And it works the other way around too. If someone blocks or mutes me, I’m actually happy, because it means I’m one step closer to my real audience. I’d rather be blocked than get aggressive replies or negative reactions to my content.
the blocked account can see you and i have tested it myself
Thanks for the clarification. They can see you but they shouldn’t be able to interact with you.
Thanks for the clarification. They can see you but they shouldn’t be able to interact with your casts, even if they can follow you.
Correct. You no longer see them, but they can be stalkers. I don’t think they should be able to follow you personally.
I also don’t think the “show less button” has been fixed since the team admitted it’s not working as they intended. But it’s been a while and I stopped using it because no action was taken and I instead mute.
It seemed to work for a few weeks for me, and now I feel like this as I see the same accounts I’m asking to show less of over and over:
This gif sums up my experience exactly which is why I went back to mute. I’ve given it a go many times and I’m tired boss.
if i see something I dont interact and eventually it comes less and less to my feed :o is this just me??
I wonder if part of it is that I often reply to the people who reply to me. Not sure if this is signaling to the algorithm that it means I also want their content served to me first thing every day. It’s why a button would be helpful, before I resort to outright ignoring people completely just because I don’t prefer their own content.
Blocked accounts can still see you but can’t interact with you. And I agree with you, the show fewer like this doesn’t do anything in the short term.
Show fewer like this explanation casts I referenced: farcaster.xyz/dwr.eth/0x7344f065 farcaster.xyz/v/0x0949d756 Notion doc on blocking (“Warpcast” is the old name for Farcaster). This doc is available via a “learn more” link on text pop up from clicking the block button. I wish similar doc were shown for mute and show fewer like this - would help with clarity.
I really miss cast preview. Apologies for my typing mistakes. Corrections: > Block The blocked account cannot interact with me. I can’t see them but they can still see me. > Mute The muted account can interact with me but I won’t know it. They can see me but I can’t see them.
I think I just need to type slower. I usually cast from phone so harder to proofread and my thumbs are not my friends sometimes lol.
It's awesome that you're pushing for clearer controls this will make Farcaster even better for everyone
Honestly, when someone's content begins to bother me too much, I just block them permanently. And yes, I don't see muted accounts on my home feed. I don't think I've ever muted anyone though, but I've blocked people. If I still want you around, I'd just leave you there but I'd never read or engage your cast. That's how I keep my sanity safe in this space.
I don’t feel bothered (upset) by anyone’s content, more just that it’s not my preference. So block for my case feels excessively strong.
Oh yeah, bothered isn't the right word. "If it isn't up to my preference" is the word I should have used.
I’m actually thinking about them too. I reckon we gotta do something for the newbies coming to Farcaster. Like, maybe their account starts at 2, but if they post spam or whatever, it drops to 0. If they’ve got good content from the jump, that should stick and help them get noticed. I feel like when people first join and see they’re not making any waves, they get bummed out and start thinking Farcaster’s some lame app. We were chatting about content yesterday, saying how super simple, low-key stuff always gets more eyes. I’m not saying Farcaster should be all basic and low-tier, just that new folks need a fair shot to shine at the start.
I hate to say it, but I think you need another button with “mute from feed only“ to accomplish what you want patricia. (hopefully you didn’t mute me or you won’t see this) 😊
That’s what I’ve asked for before and what I’m asking for now. This is my second post on the topic. Personally I think mute and block have too much overlap currently - and that mute should be “mute from feed only.” Why would an additional button help in your view?
I guess i'm saying that some people just want to mute the person without blocking or unfollowing them. it might be accomplished with a single mute with options for "all content" or just "home feed". for example - i have a relative on other platforms that i don't want to see anything that they post, but i don't want to block them from interacting with me bc that would make holidays awkward. when i mute them on twitter i don't see their replies unless i select view more replies or this reply is from someone you muted. personally, i wished it worked this way on fb or i had more control over this.
Great points. Yes, I share mostly the same annoyances. Of course, my biggest pet peeve of all is the lack of a working feed. The algo seemingly boils down to two things: - this post is Trending, so we'll push it to you - this post has been Liked by someone you follow, so we'll push it to you No thought given to the user's actual likes, past behavior... This is primitive compared to Twitter, where you can very well finetune the algo to deliver you the exact content you want - and that's in spite of Twitter messing with it regularly. OK, I understand we can't except a scrappy startup to compete with some behemoth who has worked on tweaking those levers for years. But the silence is deafening here. Subjectively, it feels like nobody at Farcaster is even *thinking* about the feed in that way. I see it as plausible the higherups think "yea what we need is to get more videos because there's great engagement with videos" and for the thinking to stop there.
I really wrote "except" instead of "expect". smh fam, fr fr. Anyway, the above felt seemingly offtopic within the char limit, but the point I'm fumbling towards is: I would understand and agree with a hypothetical view most users will NOT tweak the levers, no matter how good the levers are. But then in that case you've got to get the feed working. Give us either or give us both, Merkle.
All this said, the feed is only one part of so many things going on here structurally that still compel me to stay. I'll take Farcaster - feed woes and all - over the other platforms in their current state any day.
I get a much better experience out of Twitter personally, after heavily tuning my algo through my interaction (blocks, likes, even clicks - it's clear Twitter tracks all of this, as my own account is free of the shock content I've seen many deplore). But, I'd rather see Farcaster be an objectively better Twitter in every way, of course. Ergo I shall be known as the Algo Whiner here.
Really well articulated. I’ve run into the same issue—wanting more control over my feed without fully muting or blocking someone. Your framing of ‘space, not elimination’ captures it perfectly. A more nuanced mute option would make the experience feel much smoother
