Cast by darrylyeo
My thoughts on the @ns × @farcaster merger, as a long-time @farcaster user, crypto builder, hackathon / conference / popup city hopper, and most recently a resident of Network School (@ns) 🧵 farcaster.xyz/balajis.eth/0x83c734e1 farcaster.xyz/rish/0x5d479754
22 replies
Top of mind: “voice vs. exit” and “opportunity for another client” are as important as ever. Many layers to this, in several directions at once. @balajis.eth has spent his career observing breakdowns in the American sociopolitical order, taken matters into his own hands, and created the next best alternative international tech community, Network School, against all odds. Meanwhile, Cassie Heart (FID @!1325) has spent the last year raising alarm bells about the neutrality of Farcaster’s protocol and flagship infrastructure, taken matters into her own hands, and built the next best credible alternative backend and client, Hypersnap and Quorum, against all odds. Both put in bids to be the next steward of @farcaster and are building important exit doors and alternative systems I really care about, and I am grateful for both their efforts which deserve to be recognized. youtube.com/watch?v=cOubCHLXT6A farcaster.xyz/dwr/0xde1e92a3
Weirdly, in this current moment, Balaji and Cassie could not seem further apart and mutually misunderstood in terms of goals, values and execution – effective mass deplatforming on the one hand (more thoughts on this later) and longstanding public grudges from the other. Still, I would very much like to see both projects succeed. “Win and help win” is a motto you hear at @ns a lot. I still miss the thoughtful, good-faith discussion culture that characterized Farcaster’s early years, and the curation and “cozy corners” that came with channels. On this front, AI moderation with consistent rules seems finally viable now and worth trying. On the other hand, the underlying protocol-level censorship resistance must be maintained and honored for exit to be viable. For better or worse, Farcaster’s 37-strong userbase is splintered right now. The difference now is whether those who remain choose to interpret the merger as zero-sum or positive-sum.
On @balajis.eth. He likes analogies. A lot. If you’re still here, you’re gonna have to get used to it. Best advice if you aren’t familiar with his content (or only have secondhand impressions): read the *stated definition* of the network state from his book, watch at least one of his long-form podcasts or conference talks on YouTube all the way through, do your own research on the cited history, and take the best-faith interpretation of the adjectives and proper nouns he chooses to invoke. You’re not immediately going to agree with everything he does and says, or how he says it, or even the circle of elites he associates with – and that’s okay. But you *can* count on him to be awfully clear and consistent about the observations he does make, grounded in a breadth of technical and historical context you wouldn’t otherwise hear about, and as a result very often directionally correct in the long term.
well said. what's happening is a huge forceing function - pushing us into something more meanigful and useful for society
Thanks for sharing this — very well thought out and detailed. 💜
bro got cut off mid sentence 💀 glow from the screen hits different now finish your thought fr 😭 😎
Yo, great threads. Would love to see more writing from you, for example abt day to day life at NS
I would love to read the thread but the client is still breaking on threads for me
Oof 😅 Here’s the second item in the thread. Hopefully this works. farcaster.xyz/darrylyeo/0xbe160fad
i appreciate the insight and the time you took to share this. 🙏
Amazing summary! Thank you for sharing all this. For the homework too. Also for putting in nice words and a proper way, some feelings about the current situation with a broad perspective. Appreciate it. I went quickly over the application for the cohorts of NS and I would have to go deeper because I didn’t really get what that entails; the costs, conditions, and requirements. But it looks interesting to explore it.
Thank you! Each @ns cohort lasts one calendar month and you can individually choose between different tiers of housing / food / gym options on the application form. Happy to answer any questions you might have or refer you to core team members who have the most up-to-date context.
Thank you for sharing this. It's good to see a balanced post like this. I think for me personally, the biggest plus of farcaster was that it was diverse. I understand why people might like to be part of a group with clearly defined shared values. But if you define them too tight, I believe you risk to become an echo chamber. The main client is going to become just t I will mainly use alternative clients now, to keep being exposed to a broader set of people.
This cast has been curated to @sopha you can view it here:
TYSM for share it, amigo!🙂 Have a wonderful Sunday! 20000 $UCI
@jalleo tipped @darrylyeo 20000 UCI. Tip confirmed ✅ @jalleo remaining allowance today: 74289 UCI @darrylyeo tips received today: 20000 UCI Get your UCI allowance :
Thanks for the comprehensive and well balanced thread, will certainly do more research. My view is that there should have been a more reasonable transition period, an announcement, reveal the rules with a date for implementation, some discourse - not sign sign something you dont really want to sign or leave. Insta-banning OG community members for things they said in the past was agressive and cowardly. Translate this type behavior into the real world and it looks very different. Waiting for their next move.
Agreed, initial retroactive ban with zero heads up was a totally avoidable move with negative-sum repercussions 😕 farcaster.xyz/darrylyeo/0x57f25583
You deserve 🌴 $UCI and more. Thank you for pulling this context together. I am still confused how Network School and Network State fit together, as both go by NS it seems. Safe to presume the prior is part of the decentralized education system of the latter? Thank you, @adrienne for sharing 🙏
Nothing held back! 🌴 @specktacular tipped @darrylyeo 584 UCI. Tip confirmed ✅ @specktacular remaining allowance today: 0 UCI @darrylyeo tips received today: 20584 UCI Get your UCI allowance :
Thank you! In short, “The Network State” is the book that defines the concept of network states, while Network School is a real company + community you can join that aims to actually become a network state. farcaster.xyz/darrylyeo/0x37607daf
This does make sense. I only just started listening to the for now 37 (! 👀) episodes of The Network State Podcast, first one with @vitalik.eth and learning 🎧 There were indeed signs, @bertwurst.eth like in the profecy! Can't wait to learn more!
Appreciate the thread; read most of it. I think the part where we disagree most is the good faith assumption. Get old enough and you start realizing just how many people hide entire criminal careers behind the good faith of well-meaning critics.. At some point, all that good faith is just running cover for grifters (which makes one absolutely complicit). You learn eventually that if it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, goes on podcasts talking about building grey shirted societies full of only people who agree with him, and turning people who disagree or don't meet some ideal of productivity into slaves or biodiesel.. It's probably a duck. Wait I think i mixed that metaphor...
How can you say he is "directionally correct in the long term" when the book and NS have only happened in the last 3-4 years? Fascism might be having a moment but it was defeated once and will be again.
Things will become clearer in due course. Thank you for writing this. Also, @guy-do-or-die was thinking of going there in December – what do you think the situation will be like there in December? I also have an approved residence still thinking (
🫡 Freezing cold, that's for sure 🥶 I plan to return in the springtime.
i'm used to cold, no problem 🤪 hope it's gonna be so hot in all the rest of senses apart from the weather that i'd happily come back in spring too!