Cast by darrylyeo
Show the cast this replies toTop of mind: “voice vs. exit” and “opportunity for another client” are as important as ever. Many layers to this, in several directions at once. @balajis.eth has spent his career observing breakdowns in the American sociopolitical order, taken matters into his own hands, and created the next best alternative international tech community, Network School, against all odds. Meanwhile, Cassie Heart (FID @!1325) has spent the last year raising alarm bells about the neutrality of Farcaster’s protocol and flagship infrastructure, taken matters into her own hands, and built the next best credible alternative backend and client, Hypersnap and Quorum, against all odds. Both put in bids to be the next steward of @farcaster and are building important exit doors and alternative systems I really care about, and I am grateful for both their efforts which deserve to be recognized. youtube.com/watch?v=cOubCHLXT6A farcaster.xyz/dwr/0xde1e92a3
3 replies
Weirdly, in this current moment, Balaji and Cassie could not seem further apart and mutually misunderstood in terms of goals, values and execution – effective mass deplatforming on the one hand (more thoughts on this later) and longstanding public grudges from the other. Still, I would very much like to see both projects succeed. “Win and help win” is a motto you hear at @ns a lot. I still miss the thoughtful, good-faith discussion culture that characterized Farcaster’s early years, and the curation and “cozy corners” that came with channels. On this front, AI moderation with consistent rules seems finally viable now and worth trying. On the other hand, the underlying protocol-level censorship resistance must be maintained and honored for exit to be viable. For better or worse, Farcaster’s 37-strong userbase is splintered right now. The difference now is whether those who remain choose to interpret the merger as zero-sum or positive-sum.
On @balajis.eth. He likes analogies. A lot. If you’re still here, you’re gonna have to get used to it. Best advice if you aren’t familiar with his content (or only have secondhand impressions): read the *stated definition* of the network state from his book, watch at least one of his long-form podcasts or conference talks on YouTube all the way through, do your own research on the cited history, and take the best-faith interpretation of the adjectives and proper nouns he chooses to invoke. You’re not immediately going to agree with everything he does and says, or how he says it, or even the circle of elites he associates with – and that’s okay. But you *can* count on him to be awfully clear and consistent about the observations he does make, grounded in a breadth of technical and historical context you wouldn’t otherwise hear about, and as a result very often directionally correct in the long term.
Two things worth calling out (because I already see friends eager to misrepresent things): One – the ability to opt-in, fork or exit at any time is *literally the entire premise* of the Network State movement. You join any place or ecosystem because you like a curated set of values, rules and incentives. If it turns out you don’t love @ns’s, that’s okay. You’re actively encouraged to fork off and start a competing vision. No one will force you to continue spending time on the flagship @farcaster client or at @ns’s campus if you don’t want to. Two – @balajis.eth is not seeking to be a tyrant or a dictator. Ask him during @ns Lunch-and-Learn what his personal ambitions are within the Network State project, and he will consistently respond “Minimum-Viable Balaji”. He may also liken himself to a “reluctant” Lee Kuan Yew who peacefully sets a system in motion before passing the torch. Yes, the Singapore analogy is contradictory in isolation. The onus is on you to hear the full context.
both efforts deserve recognition, but i hope we can build alternatives without creating divisions among the people who made this community special.
well said. what's happening is a huge forceing function - pushing us into something more meanigful and useful for society