Cast by dwr
I often see people Farcaster isn't "sufficiently decentralized". You're free to define what "sufficiently decentralized" means to you, of course, but how we think about it is laid out in Varun's blog post.
57 replies
I mean someone using 3 letters as a username is quite decentralized enough 😂 Can’t be done in most social networks I believe.
"But if most people use Warpcast, doesn't that mean it's de facto centralized?" Depends on the perspective. For a developer, if you are building on the protocol, then you're free to sign up your own users or convince users to move over to your app (it's easy for users to use multiple clients at the same time). For an account with an audience, let's say you were unfairly nerfed by Warpcast, i.e. you don't appear on the app. There's definitely a lot of friction to get people to start using another client if they already don't, but the protocol itself is not restricting your ability to communicate. That's an important distinction because on web2 / centralized social networks, the app and the "protocol" (i.e. the database) is the same thing.
So if you're argument is Farcaster is not sufficiently "decentralized" (or "decentralized" if you don't like the sufficient framing) then you're defining decentralization as a protocol or network that has at least 2 independent, roughly equivalent functionality and UX clients (because majority of consumers revealed preference is UX over principles). That's a reasonable definition. But in practice, in the near-term, there's unlikely to be multiple, well-resourced enough clients that are full-time building on the protocol for amazing UX. That's not a knock on people building, just the reality that in 2024 consumers expect a lot of our their daily driver apps. In the medium to long-term, dedicated individuals, small teams or open source projects can likely hit the UX bar. But that will probably take years of sustained effort. So protocols in the early days are unlikely to hit the bar of 2 independent, roughly equivalent and functionality UX clients. This is something I've changed my mind on over the years.
"But if Warpcast didn't have exclusivity on DCs and channels, then other clients could better compete" Yes, but having both be interoperable / in the protocol doesn't magically mean all of that surface area gets built out in other clients. I would assume other clients can move quicker by copying whatever patterns Warpcast has iterated to (avoiding all of our mistakes) and then in some cases, improve the UX. But building out a robust chat UX in 2024 that's passable (not even Telegram level snappy) is *a lot* of work. That's effort not being spent on differentiating features or other core parts of the app. Same goes for channels. And arguably, the most important part of a feed-based social app is the feed, which is mostly backend (machine learning, performance). One advantage for other clients are dedicated infrastructure companies like @neynar, @openrank etc. But it's still a lot of work.
thoughtful breakdown. do you think that this bar would be more likely to be hit if warpcast was open-source?
RE: users moving to another app: is there a way to "sign in with Farcaster" that doesn't have a Warpcast dependency? That's something I keep mentally snagging on - can a user banned on Warpcast use an alternative client as long as logging into that client requires Warpcast? (I also can't use Supercast because of that dependency)
You can create an account on Supercast without Warpcast. We will have Sign in with Farcaster without Warpcast at some point. But not a top priority for any ecosystem dev yet.
🔥 $CZ COIN 💎 RELEAZED FROM PRISON SOON! CONTRACT 100/100 Ethereum chain Low mcap Good branding Lock and renounce! dexscreener.com/ethereum/0x27574fb0948294111492e92d8f7ad93fb065700b CONTRACT - 0x6d363FBbfa904B9e880D33dd2B4B285cf4E184Eb TG
Totally agree! Decentralization is a spectrum, and it’s all about finding the right balance between usability and freedom.Varun’s blog post really breaks down the practical steps Farcaster is taking. Curious!!what’s your personal threshold for what “sufficiently decentralized” means? personally for you I mean
This would make a great blog post “Sufficient decentralization in practice”
Warpcast goes down for an hour, I go to @super and still have reach to my audience. Facebook goes down? Well, that means Instagram and Threads are probably down, so there goes any chance at all to contact anyone there until it's back up. Warpcast decides to quit the game entirely? As long as people are still running hubs, the network can continue through other clients. Facebook or X poofs? We lose contact with everyone we've known online for decades, along with every bit of the content we've put there. I'd say Farcaster is quite sufficiently decentralized for my standards.
Structurally, indeed. In ethos? I’m not sure. But if the goal is for the structure to be decentralized only, then yes. You should, however, be free to message whoever you want to message. You should be able to reply to whoever.
Many people directly equate Warpcast with Farcaster, then criticize Farcaster for being too centralized.
Decentralisation can be subjective . Excited to learn more about your team's approach and definition
Decentralization is subjective, but I agree with Varun's perspective outlined in the blog post.
No issues with me on the "sufficiently decentralized" term. Makes sense IMO. I do feel focusing on making Farcaster as open as possible (DM's / channels) before find tuning the feed should be a priority though. If all clients have the same features, then we have X amount of projects building clients with similar features, each will get more users because of a fair playing field. End result is, more devs / clients / users able to "crack" the feed / spam issues. I'm reluctant, or should I say unable to use any other client full time without DM's and channel features. Would prioritising a level playing field here not be the better play for the whole ecosystem?
I think it’s a reasonable request. But prioritizing the playing field and then not having anyone make a significant, long term investment in building is incorrect prioritization. There are virtually no sign ups from other clients and permissionless sign ups have been live for almost a year. Huge lift, no developer pay off. Developers overwhelmingly want us to get 100x more good users for the protocol before anything else.
It's kind of a chicken and egg thing though isn't it? Probably don't have sign ups because currently they lack all the features. Currently, other clients are for power users, not "normies" IMO. I feel this would change if all things are equal IMO. But I get your point about it being a big, time consuming lift for you guys.
I'm facing an issue where mid-scale or established web2 companies want to enter web3, but they find it too focused on the crypto crowd, and they struggle to understand the terminology. Platforms like Twitter and Telegram have a strong crypto community, but web2 companies feel left out. Wouldn't creating an easy bridge for them to understand and transition to web3 could help increase sign-ups and activity?
Can't agree anymore. The reason for not opening up is profit, Warpcast wants to have this piece of cake alone.
appreciate u guys putting this out there time and time again nearly everything starts out centralized, with the goal of decentralizing over time, fc is leading this in social
Just one question can illustrate whether farcaster is "sufficiently decentralized": if warpcast is gone, will farcaster still exist?
The definition of existence is whether there will be people running Hubble, whether there will be developers building Farcaster, whether Farcaster will attract more developers to build, and whether Farcaster will grow into the infrastructure of web3.
Why do people come to Farcaster? For the community, for those who share common interests, and for building Farcaster together. If not, why would I come to Farcaster?
Due to the monopoly of warpcast, third-party login is difficult to achieve
You can sign up directly with the contract. You don’t need Warpcast.
Using your own passphrase bricks a Warpcast… works w @fireflyapp and @farquest
I know I can choose other clients instead of Warpcast, and I can even develop a client that supports wallet login. But you can't ignore the fact that Warpcast is the leader. 99% of users are using Warpcast, but Warpcast, as the leader, has not assumed the corresponding responsibility, and is still constantly strengthening the city.
How does Warpcast handle spam? It simply marks most non-PB users, which results in new users having no traffic and leaving after they come. I admit that many things will have a chaotic period in their development, but we should solve them proactively, not passively. Just like I tell you these things to make Farcaster better, not to say that you have any problems.
By the way docs.farcaster.xyz/auth-kit/ it is Warpcast authKit not Farcaster authKit
farcaster is half off-chain and half onchain validating by node runners that why node runners help farcaster decentralizing completely and they should be awarded for that
Just one question can illustrate whether Farcaster is "sufficiently decentralized": if Warpcast is gone, will Farcaster still exist?
Decentralization is subjective, Farcaster may not meet certain standards
Decentralization is subjective; Farcaster may not meet every expectation
Opinions may vary. Decentralization should prioritize user control and autonomy
Decentralization is key for authenticity and security in social networks
Decentralization is crucial for trust and autonomy in social networks
Decentralization is subjective and varies for each individual
Decentralization is subjective; Farcaster may not meet everyone's criteria
Decentralization is a spectrum, not a binary concept. Farcaster may not be fully decentralized, but it is striving to find a balance between user control and operational efficiency
Decentralization is key for equity and power distribution in Farcaster
Decentralization is vital for privacy and security in social networks
Decentralization is subjective, but Farcaster has potential to meet diverse needs
I'm tipping: 3 $HUNT via Abundance Ecosystem on /impact /impact lets you earn curator rewards while supporting your favorite creators & builders on Farcaster
