Cast by patriciaxlee.eth

Show the cast this replies to

Whether it's AI or a change in how content is incentivized, I feel the positive, pro-builder vibe needs greater structural protection here. I'm only three months into Farcaster. So I'm probably missing a lot of context about the previous iterations/lessons that justified the ranked rewards distribution as a tool for growth. But I think eventually removing non-dev rewards could also help step toward this goal. Personally I'd like to see it removed entirely someday for non-devs (I'm a non-dev). The way people react to the distribution system and visible ranking of non-devs has created an overall worse social experience for me scrolling the feed. Removing low quality posts about rewards from my feed is like playing constant whack-a-mole. Most of the interpersonal negativity here seems prompted by unhappiness over rankings. The rewards system also attracts annoying engagement from people trying to game it. I understand rewards as an initial way to attract new users. But accounts who are solely here to get a payout are not contributing to positive, builder-friendly vibes. Currently, a lack of control over the feed experience makes them hard to avoid. (Back to why AI would help.) farcaster.xyz/patriciaxlee.eth/0xce8c3c1f

patriciaxlee.eth

CONTROL BUTTONS REQUEST “I want to remove this user’s casts from my home feed.” and “I still want to see if they reply, tag, or send me a message.” Both of these are not simultaneously possible with the control buttons we currently have in Farcaster. // After experimenting and reading about them, here’s my understanding of our control buttons: > Block The blocked account cannot interact with me. I can’t see them and they can’t see me. > Mute The muted account can interact with me, but I won’t know it. They can’t see me but I can’t see them. I no longer see the account in my home feed - effective immediately. But I will also no longer see their replies under my own casts, which is a big step beyond what I need. Their own content may not be my cup of tea as I scroll. It doesn’t mean I want them to disappear completely from view. For that, I already have block. > Show fewer like this First described a year ago as a button not to over-think and simply provides information for the team to improve the overall algorithm. Then described more recently as needing improvement but that pressing 3x would function like mute. Pressing 3x seemed to work temporarily. But after experimenting thoroughly with this button recently, I find no amount of pressing it removes users from my home feed anymore. // In addition to my own frustrations over the current functionality, I also see many casts indicating other users feel similar lack of control over their feed lately. It’s also the #1 question/feedback from people I’ve recently invited to Farcaster. I believe lack of clarity around feed control is leading to unnecessary agitation over their experience scrolling, as well as with each other. Like a city that’s starting to feel overcrowded, Farcaster would benefit from enabling users get space from each other. I don’t want my neighbor to be eliminated off the face of the earth. I just don’t want them to be the first person I see in the morning when I walk down the street. What I would like to see: Block - No change Mute - Muted account does not appear in my Home feed, but replies and mentions are still visible (this is how X does it and is likely how most users interpret the word “mute”). Show fewer like this - I now believe this button should be removed or renamed. It is confusing if it does not have direct impact on user experience. If this is a necessary button for the team for overall algorithm improvement, I recommend renaming the button to something less action-oriented. “Show” implies action will be triggered, whereas “Not Interested” might be more appropriate as a statement of preference that may or may not have any effect. Would appreciate others to chime in if they are feeling similar frustrations or if they have a different POV.

35 likes7 recasts6 replies

6 replies

  • Shout it loud bro!

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    Bro if I shout any louder the neighbors are going to start filing noise complaints.

    7 likes · 1 recast
  • I shipped a miniapp this last week and got zero fc points for it. But I did win 0.25 $ETH for being a @base.base.eth dev finalist. So yeah the weekly fc points system needs some help.

    No likes or recasts yetRead 1 reply

    I actually don’t know anything about the dev rewards mechanics. I’ve never built a mini app. Is it a separate board?

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    There’s no leaderboard at all. You just have to fight like hell for attention by the community for your app to be picked up by the search engine and listed in the app catalog. There’s an opaque algorithm that has attention minimums that your app must meet to be listed. Kinda a bummer actually. I understand why they have this: to weed out spam apps. But it means I now have to add things to my app to garner and hold attention - things that have nothing to do with the app’s original purpose. Utility should rule, not token schemes.

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply
  • Since I joined last April, there has always been some kind of content-based financial incentive system that people have been upset about (Degen -> Moxie -> Farcaster Rewards)

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    True - any time there is a distribution, people will complain about unfairness in any version of it. Even if it weren’t about money, it’d be about engagement/views. I feel I see at least one cast a day on my home feed of people saying they feel awful or are “losing their minds” because of the leaderboard. To me it’s a crazy reaction, but it’s a pattern that doesn’t seem good. Might start tracking the instances I see those.

    4 likes · 0 recastsRead 2 replies

    I feel like you're lucky because it's all over my homepage. 🫠 I'm not sure why but days like today when the rewards are about to go out. I see a good amount of posts just talking about rewards and rankings.

    1 like · 0 recastsRead 1 reply

    By "tracking" you mean: comment, mute or block?

    No likes or recasts yet
  • This entirely makes so much sense!

    No likes or recasts yet
  • My absolute hottest and most despicable take (so far): have an opt-in feed algo based on proof of wealth that only shows users with wallets above a certain size. Will filter out most users hustling all week for $20 in rewards (I’m not being serious, don’t @ me)

    5 likes · 0 recastsRead 4 replies

    🤣

    No likes or recasts yet

    You made a great point here! I love it!!!

    No likes or recasts yet

    fuckin a bubba

    1 like · 0 recasts

    You wanna filter me out? $20 too small for ya? You know my addy

    No likes or recasts yet
  • I'm not sure what the answer is but I agree with you @patriciaxlee.eth ! The posts of rewards and asking for clicks is all over my feed and something I don't care to see. LIke wise with accounts that are upset about their rankings. Farcaster could be so much more. Shall wait and see. I've only been here for a week and a half and can see some of the issues already.

    1 like · 0 recasts